News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise and Fall of Lisp at the Jet Propulsion Lab. by logjam on Monday September 15, 2008 @01:51PM (#304872)
"The situation is particularly ironic because the argument that has been advanced for discarding Lisp in favor of C++ (and now for Java) is that JPL should use "industry best practice." The problem with this argument is twofold: first, we're confusing best practice with standard practice. The two are not the same."

To me, this is the crux. We have this ridiculous idea that "industry" drives technological advance.

Industry software "engineers" trained up in trade schools or worse, without any awareness that they are reimplementing solutions (poorly) to problems that were solved decades ago...and we get...horrible industrial monstrosities like Java (and Microsoft Windows) roaming the earth, while remote diamonds like Lisp and Scheme shine kindly down.

Re:The Rise and Fall of Lisp at the Jet Propulsion Lab. by briancooley on Monday September 15, 2008 @03:27PM (#304973)
Industry software "engineers" trained up in trade schools or worse, without any awareness that they are reimplementing solutions (poorly) to problems that were solved decades ago...and we get...horrible industrial monstrosities like Java

Since Guy Steele coauthored both the Lambda Papers (late 1970's) and the first three editions of the Java specification, I don't think that you can successfully argue that awareness of anything solved by Lisp or Scheme was a problem in the development of Java.

I always got the impression that the goal with Java was to make bad programmers better, not to create the ultimate language (e.g., see http://fishbowl.pastiche.org/2004/03/17/halfway_between_the_...)

To use a golf analogy, consider cavity back irons. The average golfer, who struggles to hit it straight, will likely play a lot better with cavity backs. But a really good golfer won't be able to shape shots easily and will feel hamstrung without his blades.

Re:The Rise and Fall of Lisp at the Jet Propulsion Lab. by tjr on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @10:53AM (#305815)
I always got the impression that the goal with Java was to make bad programmers better, not to create the ultimate language

And you would be correct...

http://people.csail.mit.edu/gregs/ll1-discuss-archive-html/m...

Re:The Rise and Fall of Lisp at the Jet Propulsion Lab. by silentbicycle on Monday September 15, 2008 @02:38PM (#304922)
"Come on, dude. You can't argue with best practices. They're the best!"

Which is the problem, I think. Their name just screams, "Quit arguing, they know better." (for increasingly nebulous values of 'they'). Aside from trying to undermine the term as a brand ("Best Practices: Because Embracing Mediocrity Looks Good On Paper"), what can you do?

Re:The Rise and Fall of Lisp at the Jet Propulsion Lab. by DaniFong on Monday September 15, 2008 @03:11PM (#304948)
Java wasn't that crazy. The basic idea of using Java for the web seemed a sane one: the only other alternative was to do something like XWindows. And then what? Are people going to use web browsers like XWindows clients? That would never fly!

(oh wait)