Not only is it clearly hostile to the aftermarket, but putting a chip that has 12V absolute maximum ratings in an environment where it could easily be shorted to the 19-20V output of the PSU seems almost like "engineered unreliability" to me.
On the other hand, when IBM/Lenovo had to solve the problem of identifying the wattage available, they used a simple and robust solution of a single resistor:
The only improvement I could make upon that scheme would be to make the correspondence between resistance and wattage monotonic, but otherwise it's an example of non-overengineering and aftermarket-friendly solution.
http://web.archive.org/web/20100329110047/http://www.laptop-...
An explanation of (one of) the design flaws:
http://web.archive.org/web/20100412160453/http://www.laptop-...
Not only is it clearly hostile to the aftermarket, but putting a chip that has 12V absolute maximum ratings in an environment where it could easily be shorted to the 19-20V output of the PSU seems almost like "engineered unreliability" to me.
On the other hand, when IBM/Lenovo had to solve the problem of identifying the wattage available, they used a simple and robust solution of a single resistor:
https://www.thinkwiki.org/wiki/Power_Connector#Signal_Pin
https://www.thinkwiki.org/wiki/Power_Connector#Signal_Pin_2
The only improvement I could make upon that scheme would be to make the correspondence between resistance and wattage monotonic, but otherwise it's an example of non-overengineering and aftermarket-friendly solution.