Re:Ask HN: Adding non-commercial clause to open source license?
by seba_dos1 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @11:27AM
(#30456603)
No, I wouldn't. Most of what I do requires Free Software licenses or sometimes even GPL compatibility, and such licenses are neither free, open nor GPL compatible. For me, such software wouldn't be much different from proprietary freeware.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Adding non-commercial clause to open source license?
by freeloaderz on Thursday February 24, 2022 @09:33PM
(#30463109)
So you wouldn't add a test case, new example, or fix a typo in the docs to gain access to an MIT equivalent license?
Re:Ask HN: Adding non-commercial clause to open source license?
by seba_dos1 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @11:34PM
(#30463753)
It's not MIT equivalent. It it was, it could be relicensed.
In many cases it's not even relevant what I would do or not, because such licenses make it not possible to integrate such code in a project under GPL, or to include it in a free distribution.
Looking at these licenses closer, I wonder if Parity could actually be considered free. Seems to my eye like it could be, but IANAL. For practical purposes, I'd probably consider it same as non-free until it's said to be DFSG-compliant. Prosperity sure isn't free though.