Re:FAA says 5G could impact radio altimeters on most Boeing ...
by helsinkiandrew on Thursday February 24, 2022 @03:31AM
(#30452255)
> Your analogy is a great demonstration why reasoning-by-analogy fails, by the way.
I hate reasoning-by-analogy in general but in this case it sounds fine to me. Boeing are grazing their cattle on someone else's land - they don't get squatters rights because no one else was using it at the time when they built their fences. Because it was contractors that built the fences and Boeing didn't perhaps know they were using someone else's land then they should get a little time to move the cattle - or the FAA/FCC can arrange a deal and give the telecom companies some new land - but it's Boeings problem.
I hate reasoning-by-analogy in general but in this case it sounds fine to me. Boeing are grazing their cattle on someone else's land - they don't get squatters rights because no one else was using it at the time when they built their fences. Because it was contractors that built the fences and Boeing didn't perhaps know they were using someone else's land then they should get a little time to move the cattle - or the FAA/FCC can arrange a deal and give the telecom companies some new land - but it's Boeings problem.