News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by moe on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:32PM (#3044021)
whats better: not messing with the environment and continuing to allow hundreds of thousands of human deaths a year.

One could argue that in the light of human overpopulation it might not be wise to remove one of our last natural predators.

A cynical stance, for sure, and it gets only more cynical when you consider that we might be trading mosquito-deaths for starvation-deaths here...

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by CWuestefeld on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @04:16PM (#3045008)
in the light of human overpopulation

Malthus might make that argument, but others, like Julian Simon, would say quite the opposite.

The Malthusian theory is that we've only got a certain amount of arable land, and thus can only support a finite number of people. Once we hit that maximum population, mankind stagnates at that point.

The competing theory -- and the one that has proven through history to be correct -- is that the most important resource, the one that outweighs all others, is the human mind. The more people we have, the more creativity we can bring to bear on a problem.

Thus, the problem of agriculture has been largely solved. Humans have invented irrigation, terracing, crop rotation, selective breeding, and genetic manipulation. We spend our time on the edge of disaster, but before we can topple over, the lure of riches to the person who can come up with the solution is sufficient to take us to the next plateau.

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by Steko on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @05:55PM (#3045419)
"proven through history to be correct"

Pretty sure you mean partially correct. The wolrd has a long history of famines that show we quite often bump up against Malthusian limits.

In the long run yes production can potentially keep pace with population but what's more relevant is the population growth rate itself will naturally fall once a certain quality of life is achieved.

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by michaelkeenan on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @06:59PM (#3045631)
> The world has a long history of famines that show we quite often bump up against Malthusian limits.

Famine isn't caused by a lack of resources - it's a political problem. 87 million people died of famine in the 20th century, but none of those were in democracies. Source (though I haven't checked the numbers myself): http://markhumphrys.com/end.war.html

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by Steko on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @10:09PM (#3046147)
To say it's a political problem is to say that you can solve all famine just by just changing over to democracy which simply isn't the case (although it would help!).

That's an error in causation. What's more likely is you're seeing the fact that democracy helps but what helps more is the same societal characteristics that are salient for developing a strong democracy (e.g. a strong, educated middle class) also tend to insulate those societies from shocks to the food supply.

Certainly type of government is important but to say famine isn't also caused by lack of resources is silly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theories_of_famines

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famine_in_India

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malnutrition_in_India

"Deaths from malnutrition on a large scale have continued across India into modern times. In Maharashtra alone, for example, there were around 45,000 childhood deaths due to mild or severe malnutrition in 2009, according to the Times of India.[145] Another Times of India report in 2010 has stated that 50% of childhood deaths in India are attributable to malnutrition.[146] Around 7.5 million people per year die of malnutrition in modern India, the largest death rate caused by malnutrition for any country."

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by CWuestefeld on Wednesday September 28, 2011 @09:00AM (#3047617)
What's more likely is you're seeing the fact that democracy helps but what helps more is the same societal characteristics that are salient for developing a strong democracy

Yes. More important than democracy itself is a strong system of property rights and a functional market (these are things that tend to be present in democracies, hence the confusion).

The problem in Africa is frequently that property rights are not respected, so warlords and gangsters are able to confiscate the food and sell it themselves, or dole it out to their minions.

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by moe on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @05:12PM (#3045257)
and the one that has proven through history to be correct

Something tells me you didn't apply the scientific method here...

We spend our time on the edge of disaster, but before we can topple over, the lure of riches to the person who can come up with the solution is sufficient to take us to the next plateau.

That's implying the pretty optimistic assumption that we're capable of solving any problem that we create for us.

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by CWuestefeld on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @05:49PM (#3045388)
Something tells me you didn't apply the scientific method here...

Actually, I've created an alternate universe to serve as a control...

Social sciences, unfortunately, aren't generally amenable to experimentation at the scale we're talking about here.

That's implying the pretty optimistic assumption that we're capable of solving any problem that we create for us.

There's a long string of data points supporting this assumption. (And I'm sure that survivorship bias isn't playing any role whatsoever ;) )

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by moe on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @06:40PM (#3045566)
Social sciences, unfortunately, aren't generally amenable to experimentation at the scale we're talking about here.

Which doesn't change the fact that "proven through history to be correct" is a meaningless claim in this context.

You don't have to be a malthusian to acknowledge that the physical resources of our planet are finite and that our track-record of dealing with similar problems on much smaller scales isn't exactly flawless.

There's a long string of data points supporting this assumption. (And I'm sure that survivorship bias isn't playing any role whatsoever ;) )

At least you're adding the winking smiley yourself. ;)

Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by ars on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @06:52PM (#3045605)
But most people with malaria don't die. Instead they experience malaise and lack of energy (due to anemia). This causes tremendous misery and suffering, keeping entire populations stuck and unable to progress - but alive.
Re:Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations by felipemnoa on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @01:39PM (#3044356)
I would call it a parasite, not a predator.