News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without ... by gruez on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:21PM (#30434006)
>And the emergencies act is being challenged in court, which will determine if this is lawful.

The difference is that in liberal democracies, the executive branches has to convince a court before they can act. eg. getting a warrant before doing a search, or getting a conviction before imprisoning someone. The approach of "shoot first, you can sue us in court later" makes a mockery of this.

>Banks are private entities. They freeze accounts engaged in illegal activities regularly. The US does too - here's one random citation. [1]

They're both bad. This is just slightly worse because the government is directing businesses into targeting their political enemies.

Re:Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without ... by sudosysgen on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:40PM (#30434257)
In this case the executive didn't do any convincing, the legislature did. It's a parliamentary system - the executive is an extension of the legislature.
Re:Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without ... by sofixa on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:51PM (#30434409)
> The difference is that in liberal democracies, the executive branches has to convince a court before they can act. eg. getting a warrant before doing a search, or getting a conviction before imprisoning someone. The approach of "shoot first, you can sue us in court later" makes a mockery of this.

Uh no, not really. I'm going to presume you're comparing with the US. Do you forget that the US kidnapped, imprisoned and murdered random people, including American citizens without any judicial oversight? Not to mention sweeping surveillance with laughable pretense of judicial oversight ( FISA courts)?

Executive branches have lots of power, and that power is controlled via checks and balances, the judicial and legislative branches ( in many countries the executive branch' power comes from the legislative and is directly beholden to it ( where PMs are sitting MPs)).

Re:Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without ... by gruez on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @05:02PM (#30434518)
>Uh no, not really. I'm going to presume you're comparing with the US. Do you forget that the US kidnapped, imprisoned and murdered random people, including American citizens without any judicial oversight? Not to mention sweeping surveillance with laughable pretense of judicial oversight ( FISA courts)?

And? That's just as bad. I'm saying canada's actions are bad because they go against how liberal democracies should work, not against how the US works in practice

>Executive branches have lots of power

That's exactly why I'm concerned.

>and that power is controlled via checks and balances, the judicial and legislative branches ( in many countries the executive branch' power comes from the legislative and is directly beholden to it ( where PMs are sitting MPs)).

And 9/11 in the US shows how easily the populace can be convinced to abandon those liberal democracy ideals given a threat.