The first is that it is a bubble chamber. People there follow their passions. This is a good thing but I believe they are out of touch with the common folk.
The second is what I perceive to be a general, blatant disregard for non-engineering and non-data-driven approaches to startups. I remember when I was figuring out my own project, I had wanted to take a more design-oriented approach to it, and one well-meaning friend suggested I create a "contest" to attract designers (i.e. get them to do some work for free). At least he didn't flick off the idea of making design of central importance, on par with engineering. I mean, what gives, right? Designers are makers too.
Make no mistake, now that I'm here, I don't think it's going to be easy or pretty here. The blatant disregard goes the other way around here. I can't shake the feeling that tech is regarded as second best, that people are cynically passion-impaired, and that good engineering is simply not appreciated outside of a few top shops like Jane St. Most of the startup engineers I meet are strangely risk-averse and used to working for MBAs, practically to the point that they seem defensive when introduced to someone who isn't. Chances are, I will probably end up back in the Valley at some point.
But to think that the Valley is invincible is wrong. The success of Twitter, Tumblr, Etsy and FourSquare are ample cues to the weaknesses of the Valley. These are not edge cases. They are a pattern. And this is fine. I think the two can coexist and learn from each other. If anything, going between the two makes you realize how arrogant each of their cultures are about themselves.
NYC tech sustainable? Yes. NYC = SV? No. And that's a good thing.
Also, Appnexus is a cloud company.
It's actually been a constant debate over the last decade since SOX came in and scared away all the international companies from listing in NY.
NY is now second in the Global Financial Centres index:
http://zyen.com/PDF/GFCI%2010.pdf
(Although NY / London / HK are all practically neck-to-neck)
They want to be a big player in cloud, so it makes the most sense for them to be located in Silicon Valley. After that, it's a network effect.
While I agree that New York has displaced Boston, it is no threat to Silicon Valley's crown: New York does adequately at some variants of software service startups (e.g., the Foursquares of the world), but it is missing virtually every other element of the ecosystem. There is no microprocessor company in NYC. There is no network equipment provider in NYC. There is no computer company in NYC. There is no handset maker in NYC. There is no cloud company in NYC. Yes, Google may have a large presence in NYC, but Intel has a large presence in Portland; a single company's large presence cannot in and of itself create an ecosystem. And that ecosystem is the difference between having a "vibrant tech scene" and being the world's epicenter for technological innovation; NYC may be the former, but is unlikely to ever displace Silicon Valley as the latter.