A legal argument, yes. Which can be tested in a court; it's his right to do so, isn't it?
He's the rights holder of a famous image and they used it commercially without permission. Dealing with it legally is not inappropriate, IMO.
Like I say, I think if they'd asked him nicely before just either assuming they had the right, or alternately assuming he'd be OK with it, they might have had a different outcome. They did not.
Begging the question - they made their own image, and then Maisel claimed it infringed his. You can agree with that claim if you like, but if someone made a directly comparable claim about a software license I think most of HN would rightly find it absurd.
> they made their own image, and then Maisel claimed it infringed his
This is obtuse.
The question at issue was whether it was *fair* use -- to make a fair use claim you are stipulating it is a *use*. I am not convinced either way.
This seems kind of disingenuous. People were mad that Maisel threatened a lawsuit in a case where there's a strong, obvious argument for fair use. If something directly comparable happened with software licenses I think most of the HN community would react the same way they have here.