News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by Tenoke on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:30PM (#30410642)
>I’m trying to question the coherence of the proposition itself, and not trying to refute an argument in favor of it.

The point is that just because you can't prove something to yourself it doesn't make the belief incoherent. And you can use your other tools to arrive at likelihoods for said belief.

At any rate, there's plenty of things we believe about say quantum mechanics without being able to observe them directly by using theory and observing secondary effects.

In theory it's also possible to eventually have an exact definition of what we mean by consciousness, figure out which parts of the brain are relevant in what ways and observe secondary effects and use theory to confirm others have it same as with QM. It's all caused by physical effects and at a higher level than things we already reason about just fine.

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by burrows on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:47PM (#30410738)
> The point is that just because you can't prove something to yourself it doesn't make the belief incoherent.

If a proposition doesn’t make predictions about my empirical experience then what is it saying?

And if a proposition does make such empirical predictions, than it’s effectively just a name for those predictions.

That’s essentially the view I’m coming from.

> At any rate, there's plenty of things we believe about say quantum mechanics without being able to observe them directly by using theory and observing secondary effects.

I don’t know any physics so I can’t comment.

Why are propositions about consciousness different from propositions about faeries?

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by Tenoke on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:59PM (#30410805)
>Why are propositions about consciousness different from propositions about faeries?

Ultimately they are not. It's just that the evidence points towards an extremely low chance of fairies being real and extremely high chance of others being conscious in a comparable manner to how you are conscious.

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by burrows on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:47PM (#30411080)
So then is one of these propositions true?

Every North American faerie weighs more than 10kg.

Every North American faerie weighs 10kg or less.

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by josephcsible on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:54PM (#30411114)
Both of those propositions are true. I don't see the connection to consciousness though.
Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by burrows on Sunday February 20, 2022 @09:30PM (#30411325)
Are there truths that are neither tautological (mathematical) nor empirical? I would suggest those statements are only meaningful if in principle we could measure the weight of a faerie.

As another example, I suggest that “Every idea weighs more than 10kg” and “Every idea weighs 10kg or less” are both not meaningful, because it is not possible to measure the weight of a given idea.

And so consider a claim like, “Consciousness has property X”, how can I decide whether or not such a claim is true?

edit: That last claim should have been, “Some other person’s consciousness has property X”.