News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by jstx1 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:48PM (#30410017)
> Here's a hint, if you want to refute an idea, refute the actual idea,

Science doesn't work that way - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by tpoacher on Sunday February 20, 2022 @06:30PM (#30410286)
Definitions don't fall under falsifiability though.

If I define "zorg" as colour #ff45b3, arguing "this is not the case because it can't be disproven" is rather silly.

Similarly if I say AI is "slightly conscious" as per my definition of consciousness, and a critic says it's not given their definition, they're both right (but in a totally uninteresting manner).

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by candiodari on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:38PM (#30410681)
Which science is that, that requires falsifiability?

English? A made up word that gets used certainly is a worthy object of study in that science. Similar points can be made about all humanist sciences.

Natural sciences? Say, Biology. Fictional, and therefore unfalsifiable, biological systems, in the context of the search for extraterrestrial life or just generally (e.g. can we have living silicon-based life?) are objects of study.

Physics? Only experimental physics requires falsifiability. That a large part of it is in fact searching for falsifiability illustrates, I hope, that falsifiability is not a requirement for 99% of Physics. String theory is famous for being unfalsifiable.

Math? Unfalsifiable theories are seen as a good thing in math, and are certainly objects of study. That we don't have a good unfalsifiable set theory for over a century is one of the great problems in math.

You might say I'm a utilitarian. But so is everyone else, despite a few people being confused. Of course, that's exactly what a utilitarian would say.

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by the_af on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:43PM (#30411738)
> String theory is famous for being unfalsifiable.

Yeah, but this is a reason why lots of physicists disregard string theory as a dead end.

Re:Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can d... by xvilka on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:12PM (#30411564)
String theory is falsifiable, just it requires so much energy that we cannot operate with in any foreseeable future.