Re:Linux's GPLv2 licence is routinely violated (2015)
by butlerm on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:53AM
(#30413806)
Thanks for the clarification on that. Either way, MAI v. Peak was kind of a disastrous decision that presumably could have easily been resolved under fair use for the service contractor. Congress included Section 107 for a reason, and no doubt part of the logic is that courts use it instead of creating a make work program for Congress on the subject.
That would seem to go double for whichever court decided that ephemeral copies in RAM are "fixed" in a "tangible medium of expression", in direct contradiction of the plain meaning of the term.
That's not entirely true, as far as I understand. The rule that a user may copy the work to RAM as a fair-use exemption already existed at the time of MAI v Peak. However, it was found not to apply, since the person that loaded the program into memory was not MAI's client, but a Peak employee, who was fulfilling a separate contract with MAI's client, and who had never legally obtained a copy of the work from MAI (which would have entitled them to load it in memory themselves).
Basically, the court at the time found that if I have a copy of Windows from MS, I am allowed to copy it into memory and run it. But, a repairman I hire is not allowed to load my copy into memory and run it themselves, unless they also legally own a copy of Windows.
However, Congress did amend copyright law in light of MAI v Peak, to extend the existing fair use exemption for copying into RAM to people acting as service/repair contractors.