Take Google+ for instance - they could have at least attempted a decentralized social network, but they didn't. Instead they are requiring real names, because apparently pseudonyms are bad for Google ... and yet being anonymous is something which the web (in general) not only allows, but also encourages.
Yes, you can choose not to use Google+ or Facebook, but for how long will this freedom last when absolutely everybody will be on one of these social networks? How long will it last until email will not be the primary means of communicating at work with your customers or colleagues?
It's a pity that the millions of users with accounts on Facebook haven't discovered the advantages of opening up an account on Wordpress.com or similar services, with their own domain name ; or the advantages of using Google Reader to follow your acquaintances.
I agree with you that G+ would be better decentralized, and based on open standards. But I think they tried that with Buzz and Wave, both catastrophic failures. And I think the strategy this time is to try to nail down the user experience first. I think the real names policy is a part of that, too (though I agree, too, that this is a bad policy).[0]
Could all be wishful thinking, I suppose.
[0]: Some weak evidence for this being the strategy: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3019052
> Activity Streams, PoCo, OAuth 2. I feel like the girl in Jurassic Park. "I know this!"
https://plus.google.com/104323674441008487802/posts/jJNsUDPc...
So, you couldn't get more open and decentralized than that. G+ api is read only for now though but the devs made it clear that it won't stay that way.
(As a bonus, this would neatly sidestep the ano/pseudonymity issue.)
So, when I can run byjoemoon+ on my own server and interoperate with G+ users with complete feature parity, I'll be really happy.
Meanwhile, I think the API stuff is great, but only a half-measure.
Isn't this where open source platforms like Linux come in? Linux has been fighting for desktop adoption for decades, but the surrounding projects (Cairo, Pango, etc) that support that effort have evolved a tremendously powerful platform. An open source project could easily build and popularize an alternative to HTML and the like.
The problem I see is the entrenched HTML output (both static and from dynamic generation) of billions of websites. The longer HTML is entrenched, the bigger the leverage it has. And that entrenchment isn't wholly without merit either. Resolution and viewport independent UIs, especially over such a broad range, are incredibly difficult.
That said, I fully expect things like onmouseover scripts to disappear as we try to learn new UI ideas for multitouch devices.
[0]: I wrote a bit more about that here: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/166900257/why-i-trust-google
And a bit about the problems around the particular relationship Google has with the web here: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/7590977101/googles-existentia...