Re:Ask HN: How to explain the luck of being a human being an...
by layer8 on Friday February 18, 2022 @06:09PM
(#30392415)
The mistake, I believe, is to think of an identity separate from being. If "you" were an insect, someone else would be the particular human you are now. That world would be identical to this world. In reality, both the particular insect exists and the particular human exists. There is no “luck of the draw” that would assign identities (“selfs”) to those existences. What could be said is that the reason you are contemplating this question is that you are that particular human being.
That being said, I’m well aware of the curious feeling of the realization that one is the particular consciousness that one is and not any other, and that it seems quite random (and lucky or unlucky, depending on your circumstances). But in the end it’s kind of an illusion, because what would be the alternative? For any being X, of course they are that being X and no other! There is no way it could be any different.
That being said, I’m well aware of the curious feeling of the realization that one is the particular consciousness that one is and not any other, and that it seems quite random (and lucky or unlucky, depending on your circumstances). But in the end it’s kind of an illusion, because what would be the alternative? For any being X, of course they are that being X and no other! There is no way it could be any different.