News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Teaching Handwriting by whacked_new on Sunday September 14, 2008 @10:01AM (#303754)
Agreed! A third grade kid who confuses the direction of the hook of a 'G' when writing it himself does not indicate that writing is obsolete. It indicates a failure of parenting.

Now I wonder if this sort of article should be tolerated simply because it generates discussion...

Re:Stop Teaching Handwriting by queensnake on Sunday September 14, 2008 @10:35AM (#303774)
He might be dyslexic or something. She's got a point.
Re:Stop Teaching Handwriting by whacked_new on Sunday September 14, 2008 @12:00PM (#303833)
I did consider the case of being dyslexic, in which case he wouldn't just have a problem with handwriting, but also with reading and writing in general, regardless of medium. At the age of 8 or 9, you'd expect the kid to already have it diagnosed and actions taken.

But you made me re-read the article (actually the middle three paragraphs, which I skipped because the intro and final paragraphs weren't interesting). Fair enough -- she has a point. It could be about cursive, stupid teachers, bad curricula, schooling, or just handwriting in general. Not sure which, and that the title is incendiary and that she stated her profession in the intro just doesn't do it for me. I admit my comment was untamed though.

Re:Stop Teaching Handwriting by timcederman on Sunday September 14, 2008 @05:36PM (#304053)
The arguing from authority really bugged me too, and as such I also skipped the same stuff...
Re:Stop Teaching Handwriting by michael_dorfman on Sunday September 14, 2008 @11:43AM (#303828)
He's dyslexic, therefore schools shouldn't teach handwriting?

Care to fill out the missing steps in the syllogism, to make the "point" you think she's got?