Re:Elastic and Amazon reach agreement on trademark infringem...
by theamk on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @08:03PM
(#30368272)
You say "system has big problems"... so if you had magic power to pass any law and have everyone follow it, what would that law be?
I am guessing you didn't like how Amazon was profiting from ElasticSearch's work.. so would you retrospectively change ElasticSearch's license to SSPL? Or maybe help all companies: prohibit all permissive licenses (Apache, MIT, BSD etc..) entirely and force people to either AGPL, SSPL or fully commercial? Or make a law that no free software license may apply to companies with >$1 billion in revenue?
While we are at it, how about prohibiting commercial flat-rate unlimited site licenses? The huge companies can take advantage of those too.
The thing is, I bet Elastic's original decision to use Apache was to get more users, at the expense of also getting more competition. Now they have their users but they don't like the price they paid for it. This may have been a bad business decision on their part.. but I don't see "big problems" there, companies make bad business decisions all the time.
Re:Elastic and Amazon reach agreement on trademark infringem...
by joking on Thursday February 17, 2022 @01:55AM
(#30370265)
Don’t forget that the core of elastic is lucene, the full text library that is also the core of solr and that has an Apache license, without lucene elastic wouldn’t exist.
I am guessing you didn't like how Amazon was profiting from ElasticSearch's work.. so would you retrospectively change ElasticSearch's license to SSPL? Or maybe help all companies: prohibit all permissive licenses (Apache, MIT, BSD etc..) entirely and force people to either AGPL, SSPL or fully commercial? Or make a law that no free software license may apply to companies with >$1 billion in revenue?
While we are at it, how about prohibiting commercial flat-rate unlimited site licenses? The huge companies can take advantage of those too.
The thing is, I bet Elastic's original decision to use Apache was to get more users, at the expense of also getting more competition. Now they have their users but they don't like the price they paid for it. This may have been a bad business decision on their part.. but I don't see "big problems" there, companies make bad business decisions all the time.