Re:Why Facebook's 'Frictionless Sharing' violates HTTP
by jaekwon on Sunday September 25, 2011 @03:17PM
(#3036500)
Does a URL shortener violate HTTP when it offers analytics on GET links to the public?
I think the OP should understand that HTTP is a leaky abstraction.
GET requests always have some side effect, either on the server end or the client end.
Server A and Server B.
A GETs B's data and and offers a mutated version of it, which B GETs, and further mutates. Side effects with no POSTS! This is natural too, in a distributed environment, since each agent should be responsible for mutating its own state, rather than have B POST something to A. You can't abstract this dynamics into HTTP, but you can use HTTP to handle the underlying communication mechanics, like caching and authorization.
I think the OP should understand that HTTP is a leaky abstraction.
GET requests always have some side effect, either on the server end or the client end.
Server A and Server B.
A GETs B's data and and offers a mutated version of it, which B GETs, and further mutates. Side effects with no POSTS! This is natural too, in a distributed environment, since each agent should be responsible for mutating its own state, rather than have B POST something to A. You can't abstract this dynamics into HTTP, but you can use HTTP to handle the underlying communication mechanics, like caching and authorization.