News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by dragontamer on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:43PM (#30363052)
I don't know the details.

What I do know is that the older reactors weren't really the type that could "spin up" or "spin down". Control rods always existed on nuclear power plants, even the oldest designs.

-------

In any case: "Connecting" those rods up to a computer so that the reaction can get hotter or run cooler would be the basis for variable power output.

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by jcrawfordor on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:56PM (#30363254)
I'm not an expert but my general understanding is that neutron poisoning is the big issue. Most reactors are designed around a careful balance of operating temperature and radiation field to mitigate neutron poisoning by the fuel, and operating outside of that balance will cause the problem to become progressively worse until the reaction is no longer self sustaining. So reactors have a "design power" and they can operate outside of that design power only for limited periods of time, while transitioning in and out of operation. Operating outside of the design power for too long causes thermal output to get lower and lower until the reactor just needs to be shut down while the operators wait out the half-life of the short-lived fuel products that cause poisoning, and then they can start it up again. I think this can be weeks so it's carefully avoided.
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by littlestymaar on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:01PM (#30363316)
You are right about the (mostly Xenon-induced) neutron poisoning being a important design factor, but there's still quite a lot of margin you can use to modulate power (reducing boric acid concentration in water is the key factor here, so it will works better when the fuel has been renewed recently than just before you need to refuel).
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by Lascaille on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:46PM (#30363110)
>would be the basis for variable power output.

This has been done literally forever. Why do you think nuclear plants run at 100% capacity 24/7?

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by dragontamer on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:47PM (#30363140)
> Why do you think nuclear plants run at 100% capacity 24/7?

The primary reason would be economic. Fuel costs IIRC are really low but capital-expenses (especially safety engineering / politics / convincing the people nearby that the plant is safe) is so costly.

When you have cheap-fuel but expensive machines, it makes sense to run closer to 100%. If you have expensive fuel but cheap machines (ex: Gas turbines), it makes sense to run in a "peaker" fashion.

-----

That being said: I've heard that older nuclear plants are "baseload" designs, in that they _CANNOT_ turn off or feasibly regulate their power output.

I mean, they obviously "can" turn off, they all have control rods for safety. But they're clearly not using them to regulate the power output.

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by Lascaille on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:51PM (#30363188)
>But they're clearly not using them to regulate the power output.

No, you heard wrong. They're often the last or second to last type of plant that's called upon to alter supply to match demand, but they don't run 100% 24/7.

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by cinntaile on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:54PM (#30363229)
They want to run them nearly 100% 24/7 for economic reasons though. Also what is the effect of regulating with control rods on the fuel, does it have an impact on how often the fuel needs to be changed?
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by Lascaille on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:40PM (#30363885)
>does it have an impact on how often the fuel needs to be changed

Yes, fissonable elements in the fuel are consumed in a manner that's proportional to output. So if you run at 25% output your fuel needs to be changed (example) every 4 years, if you run at 100% output your fuel needs to be changed every year.

But it is not 100% proportional, for example, 15% of the plant's output is required simply to run the plant's accessories. So it is advantageous to run at 100% output if you can.

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by cinntaile on Thursday February 17, 2022 @09:09AM (#30373182)
Another comment in this thread, I can't find it now, said that lower output past a certain level did lead to having to change the fuel faster. I don't know who's correct but it feels strange that this would be a linear relationship, these kinds of things don't tend to work like that.
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by cinntaile on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:52PM (#30363204)
I recall reading that the fuel is 1/3 of the operating expenses, but I could be misremembering.
Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by ch4s3 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:05PM (#30365010)
About 28% as of 2018[1], but there have been some advancements since then. Half of that cost is enrichment and fabrication, and disposal is a factor too. It costs a lot less to fuel nuclear plants than coal plants, but maintenance is more costly for nuclear. Pricing in externalities or requiring scrubbers makes coal FAR more expensive. Natural gas is really cheap right now so that is largely what is undercutting Nuclear for base load power. It's worth noting that historically natural gas production/use has been far more dangerous than nuclear and far less scrutinized by regulators.

[1]http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2018/ph241/wang-k2/

Re:US DOE to offer $6B to keep struggling nuclear reactors o... by jcrawfordor on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:03PM (#30363331)
Most nuclear power plants in the US fleet are not variable-output for design reasons. Mostly, both the reactor (see my other comment about neutron poisoning) and turbines are designed for safe operation at a fixed output and cannot operate at "partial" power for extended periods (in the turbines I think the problem is vibration and how it interacts with the bearing designs). A lot of this basically comes from these reactors having been designed without the benefit of computer modeling (everything had to be hand-calculated around a specific target output), newer designs based on computational modeling and optimization techniques achieve much larger safe/sustainable power ranges. Unfortunately we have very few reactors of modern design in the US.