News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:18AM (#30361045)
When you're in the middle of a hard fought war you do not have the certainty afforded by history. Everything is at stake. You may think you're ahead but then you suffer unthinkable losses (the battle of the bulge, for example --for both sides and the Korean war). With large scale wars where both sides both have a chance at winning, it's not over till it's over. You have no idea what will happen you cannot afford to say, "I think we'll win, let's pull back". Your fleet can be sunk, your ally can fall unpredictably (leadership death), etc.

You also have to remember, the Axis Japanese were extremely brutal in war. The allies could not afford to think, "maybe they'll turn nice".

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by syki on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:24AM (#30361135)
We can go back and forth and quibble over using the word “murder” as you have and quibble over who ultimately is to blame. I won’t convince you of anything and likewise you won’t convince me of anything. War truly is hell and after the way the Japanese conducted themselves during the war there’s a certain karma involved in terms of them getting the total war they so desired.

War sucks. My dad fought in World War 2. Frontline soldier in Western Europe in Patton’s Third Army. His battalion war book has the names of the dead and many are underlined in red because those are the ones he knew. He was a drunk and abusive and obviously suffered from untreated PTSD.

His division was preparing to transfer to the Pacific when the atomic bombs were dropped. He appreciated that as a result the Japanese surrendered (at least it appeared to be a causal effect from his perspective). Who can possibly calculate the efficacy of the alternatives even in retrospect? It’s easy to criticize after the fact. Are you so certain you’d have decided differently than Curtis LeMay were you in his position?

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:32AM (#30361254)
I am not necessarily saying the choice was wrong. It was one bad option out of many.

However, I am challenging the incredibly strong urge people have to absolve those who made the choice of any kind of responsibility for having made it. You will see it even in the responses to this comment. We absolutely refuse to even acknowledge that a choice was, in fact, made to kill all of these innocent civilians.

The person I responded to is struggling to understand how the Japanese reacted to this. But he is paying absolute zero mind to the actions and reactions of those on his own side, who chose to bring this tragedy about.

The very idea of thinking about the acts committed by your own side is strongly, strongly taboo.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by nradov on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:56AM (#30361634)
I absolve those who made the choice of any kind of responsibility for protecting enemy civilians. Their only responsibility was towards Americans. If their choice saved even one American life then in context it was the right choice. How could they possibly ask Americans to contine dying if they had the means to shorten the war?
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by lowbloodsugar on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:25PM (#30363671)
While it is true that many will absolve the decision makers without thinking, or with thoughts of revenge, a deeper analysis shows that it was a reasonable decision. You write them off as "strongly, strongly taboo". Is that as far as that goes then? Wasn't everything, starting with Pearl Harbor, strongly, strongly taboo? Is it ok to murder someone just because they are in a uniform, because two humans, who we will call "kings", or "emperors", or "presidents" have a disagreements? Bottom line you're walking into a moral discussion about war with the idea "killing is bad". Think you need to up your game.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:52AM (#30362334)
I don't think anybody denies this choice was made. Of course it was.

They made it earlier in the war. Civilians were the war economy and civilians were legit targets for all nations in war.

Civilians in a total war are just not typical civilians. Everybody in society was mobilized for war.

> The very idea of thinking about the acts committed by your own side is strongly, strongly taboo.

No it isn't. Lots of historians work on that. There are lots of talks about it in places like WW2 History Museum and so on.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by gus_massa on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:08PM (#30362526)
> Civilians were the war economy and civilians were legit targets for all nations in war.

That's not what the Geneva Conventions says.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:29PM (#30362806)
The Geneva Conventions from 1949?

Before there there was Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907. Those were violated in WW1 on a large scale and no alternative had been put into place.

All these things are good and nice, but the reality is, if disagreeing with these is vital to win a war, literally no nation followed them.

Those kinds of agreements are good attempts in peace time to improve the chance of good outcomes, but in reality, in major global they are just pieces of papers that can not be enforced.

If you want to run around and simply say everybody is evil, then you can do that. But if you actually put yourself in the position of those people and try to make decisions if you want to be critical, explain what and how you would have done things differently.

And what cost would you have been willing to engage in to achieve that moral high ground.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by onychomys on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:31AM (#30361230)
I'm pretty sure I didn't actually pass any judgement one way or the other on the actions of the US military in that post. The two are morally separate, we don't have to do a what-about-ism for it.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:33AM (#30361280)
Indeed you didn't. But you jumped immediately very strongly to one question, rather than to another. You have been conditioned all your life to question the decisions of the enemy, but to never, ever question the decisions of your own side.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by onychomys on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:58AM (#30361660)
Or maybe I was making a conscious choice to comment on the one but not the other. In the last 20 years or so, there's been a wide reconsideration about the morality of dropping bombs (whether nuclear or conventional) on civilian populations during the war. I don't think we need to have yet another conversation about that. Instead, I'm trying to understand the Japanese viewpoint, where they get a telegram that 100k people have been killed in a raid and think "Bummer, but we fight on!".
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:21PM (#30365856)
Has there really been "wide reconsideration" of that?

Or do we like to pretend there has, and that's all done now, but still treat the subject as taboo and avoid it?

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by bcrosby95 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:22PM (#30365192)
We're all just fleas on the backs of wolves.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by DiffEq on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:20AM (#30361075)
This is a good questions and deserves an answer. The decision to murder one hundred thousand human beings was made not by the leadership of the United States but by the Japanese Imperial command when they decided to start and continue the war. So the blood of these people is on the hands of the Japanese Imperial Command and none else.

This is also the case when a murderer is put to death for their crime. The murderer is responsible for the person he killed and his own death; the state who put him to death is not responsible for his murder.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:29AM (#30361199)
Absolutely not. Every person involved made a choice, of their own free will. You do not get to absolve the ones you like of responsibility and instead put it all on those who you do not.

Choices were made. They had consequences.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by DiffEq on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:14PM (#30362612)
Are you saying that U.S. leadership is responsible for the murders of those that were killed in the strategic bombing of Japan? If you are - then you are wrong.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Thursday February 17, 2022 @07:29AM (#30372355)
Did they make the decision to kill those people?