I am okay with self-identified employees rather than astroturfing. Nicks themselves have mentioned how Reddit attention helped them stay afloat, and how much of a boon it has been for PNW bootmakers. IMO this is a far better outcome than that industry dying, the manufacturing parcelled to China/SE Asia and a storied bootmaker ultimately resurrected as a Frankenstein fast fashion brand. Wesco, for example is doing great because of online attention.
However, even before Reddit, StyleForum was great, and their original darling was Viberg.
The small group of GYW brands seem to at least be generally aware that a community of enthusiasts exists on Reddit and that's probably enough to start being skeptical of positive reviews.