Re:Hey CS Paper writers, please show your code
by wisty on Saturday September 24, 2011 @06:32PM
(#3034507)
OK, but there's no way subtle bugs will be found unless the code is released. If you replicate a non-trivial piece of code, both will have bugs, and both will have subtle design trade-offs (which won't be documented in the paper). Will you publish your results, despite the fact that they don't agree with the existing, accepted ones? If you do, what will it achieve?
Of course, reimplementation can be quite time consuming, which is the main problem. But then sharing code can actually decrease the likelihood of anyone ever reimplementing the algorithm again, instead just re-using the same (possibly buggy) code forever without looking at it.