News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App Store: I'm out by axod on Saturday September 13, 2008 @05:17PM (#303358)
This is getting a little boring. Obviously Apple are going to reject apps that are a little too close to their existing apps, or might cause offense, or dumb down their product.

They built it, they own the ecosystem, so they get to decide.

Don't like it? Write a webapp instead.

Re:App Store: I'm out by henning on Saturday September 13, 2008 @07:39PM (#303466)
That's stupid. If someone makes a better podcatcher than Apple for the iPhone, the iPhone does podcasting better than before which sells more iPhones, which makes Apple richer. I don't see why it's such a threat.

Any time you implement a feature for a product you have to do it in a way that can't possibly please everyone. If you let your developers implement alternative versions, it's conceivable you could get close to pleasing everyone, which makes your product better because it then covers obscure use cases that you can't afford to deal with. It becomes as if third parties are developing the product for you for free.

Re:App Store: I'm out by apu on Saturday September 13, 2008 @08:25PM (#303497)
That might be the logical conclusion, but I don't think Apple sees it that way. They've never been very big on this "third-party" stuff...
Re:App Store: I'm out by shard on Sunday September 14, 2008 @09:58PM (#304223)
They've changed their tune ever since the iPod (hmm unintentional pun). A huge industry exists to make iPod compatible products. Apple is never going to make an iDJ.
Re:App Store: I'm out by zenspider on Saturday September 13, 2008 @09:14PM (#303519)
Someone is always going to bitch about apple. period.

Hypothetical example: What if apple is already working on a better podcasting app that works on the iphone, yet they _don't_ reject any apps?

Then, when their podcasting app comes out and kills off the competitors (usually because it is free--but also because they write damn good apps), then some author is going to bitch about how apple targeted them and killed their app. Sounding like that whiny sandvox guy doesn't do anyone any good.

Maybe... just maybe... this is the better alternative.

Personally, I'm going to write the quickest/smallest app I can that gets the 1.0 beta 1 idea into form. I'll apply with that. If I get accepted, great. I'll pump out a lot of releases getting it to 1.0 final. If not? I didn't lose that much time/effort.

Re:App Store: I'm out by netcan on Saturday September 13, 2008 @07:31PM (#303460)
I'm not so sure. I think it is substantial. Duplicating the devices' core functionalities could be a substantial area of development.

It was never 100% clear that Apple would bar that. It still isn't.

Re:App Store: I'm out by carterschonwald on Saturday September 13, 2008 @06:25PM (#303411)
I agree, complaining about it won't change it unless apple has a genuine economic incentive.

personally, I don't see whats particularly troublesome about the current policy. Granted, I'm focusing moreso on cooking up apps that are genuinely distinct in functionality to minimize the need to focus on marketing to begin with.