Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux...
by notahacker on Monday February 14, 2022 @10:20AM
(#30333040)
> in Fahrenheit 451 they're burning books because the mental model of how ideas flow was still centered around print media with publishers/printers, one-writer-many-readers, etc.
Bradbury's model in Fahrenheit 451 is even more specific than that: the books are full of diverse intellectual ideas and the TVs are so full of trash we're supposed to be pleased when Montag turns his flamethrower on them...
The kind of interactive conversation we take for granted today, where anyone can post, and where the reactions of others are immediately visible and part of the experience of not just seeing but finding content, was understandably not foreseen by Bradbury in 1953. But now that we've arrived here, don't we need better and more up to date models for how to think about censorship? In particular, issues/mechanisms which aren't really central in my memory of Bradbury were:
- facticity: is deliberate misinformation a more legitimate target for suppression?
- equity among different types of actors: e.g. the FDA doesn't allow a manufacturer or distributor of Ivermectin to say that it is an effective Covid treatment. Should non-affiliated parties be able to say it, and be paid to say it?
- financial incentives for "inflammatory" (pun intended) content
Flattening it all to just the presence or absence of any mechanism of suppressing content, irrespective of who is doing it, how, or why I think actually hinders our ability to have the nuanced conversation which Wills would claim to be defending.
And if you _do_ want to talk about Bradbury's prescience, I think Joe Rogan is the wrong example to pick right now. There are plenty of contemporary examples of states or local school boards trying to ban concepts from the curriculum, or books, in a way which is a lot more directly aligned, and aren't weighed down by the same baggage.