News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by vadiml on Saturday September 24, 2011 @10:23AM (#3033266)
I wonder i somebody took a time to really read what the petition says. The title is anti-sofware patents but the body is more complicated: "The patent office's original interpretation of software as language and therefor patentable is much closer to reality and more productive for innovation than it's current practice of issuing software patents with no understanding of the patents being issued".

I think it should read: "The patent office's original interpretation of software as language and therefor not patentable is much closer to reality and more productive for innovation than it's current practice of issuing software patents with no understanding of the patents being issued."

Or am I missing something?

Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by alain94040 on Saturday September 24, 2011 @11:20AM (#3033402)
Exactly. I didn't sign it because I read the text, had no clue what it meant, so I refused to sign, despite the name. And I wrote patents and experienced firsthand the fun of patent litigation.

My position is closer to Jonathan Abrams' tweet: tell the USPTO to stop issuing obvious patents, no matter what form.

Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by nextparadigms on Saturday September 24, 2011 @10:29AM (#3033284)
I wonder if the creator of the petition even noticed the mistake, or he can't edit it anymore. Would that be a real problem giving the title and some of the body are clearly anti-software patents?
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by Lost_BiomedE on Saturday September 24, 2011 @11:01AM (#3033364)
Yes, the creator posted in another thread that that they wont let him edit it. He also said it was accidentally sent prematurely before a good proof-read, due to the system not being intuitive to him at the moment.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by grannyg00se on Saturday September 24, 2011 @11:31AM (#3033434)
For me the problem is that there is frequently "no understanding of the patents being issued". Aside from that, if you are attempting to patent an idea or process I don't see why software should be treated differently than hardware.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by TruthElixirX on Saturday September 24, 2011 @12:44PM (#3033629)
Because software can already be copyrighted.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by hugh3 on Saturday September 24, 2011 @03:46PM (#3034174)
Surely software copyright prevents reusing of the same source code, but not a different implementation of the same algorithm?
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by thehotdon on Saturday September 24, 2011 @04:02PM (#3034197)
Yes, and that's how it should be. Mathematics, including algorithms, is not patentable.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by grannyg00se on Sunday September 25, 2011 @09:07AM (#3035732)
Why shouldn't they be patentable. If your company spends money and time comig up with a novel way to sort or search or compress information, why should you not be afforded the same protections as a company that came up with a novel way to store energy, or convert energy?
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by slowpoke on Sunday September 25, 2011 @02:31PM (#3036397)
The "time and money" argument (financial incentive to innovate) is as old as it is irrelevant. Frankly, I don't care if you can't make money off the monopoly rents of an abstract concept (and I'm offended that you think I should). What I care about is you thinking you are entitled to halt progress for your own selfish goals.

Besides, it's fallacious to imply that people need "incentives" to innovate. I'd wager there are much more people who are hindered by the patent system than there are people who would stop innovating just because there's no more monopoly to be had by being the first to apply for some legalese nonsense.

It's utterly absurd to imply any sort of ownership or rights to an abstract concept. The very notion of it should be grounds for attesting insanity. Instead, we should focus on free flow and exchange of ideas, tight cooperation and incremental development off each others' discoveries.

So no, they shouldn't be patentable. Nothing should be.

Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by grannyg00se on Thursday September 29, 2011 @11:43PM (#3055561)
So you disapprove of any type of ownership over an idea. I understand that on a certain level. I suppose first to market would be the only commercial advantage to an invention then. That's not so bad but on a ten year expense to invent you arent getting much return if your idea can be replicated in a one month copycat product. Then again....it seems you are also not fond of personal gain or reward for one's efforts. That I can't really relate to. I don't think that everything I invent should be for the progress of all mankind.
Re:White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit by shareme on Saturday September 24, 2011 @10:44AM (#3033317)
No that is generally how the whitehouse miss-writes laws issued..just wait for the over-correction being worse than the original