Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux...
by lordnacho on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:42AM
(#30332549)
Yeah I recognise some of that, but politically I see both lefty and righty opinions here, with a fair bit of nuance. You can also bring in concepts that an economics undergrad would know and people will recognise it, rather than act like you just made it up and ignore it, like it happens everywhere else. Basically I feel like a somewhat educated view is worthwhile to put forward here, rather than on FB where it really is just memes that work.
But you're right, some opinions are still more popular here than others, and some opinions are immediate karma bombs.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux...
by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:43AM
(#30332550)
There's also aggressive pruning of anything not on topic and a much stricter code of behavior than a place like Reddit or Facebook. I think it's important to do, and while I've been on the wrong side of content removal before and I don't begrudge it at all, but I don't know how people could look at this community and think it's intrinsically better by being freer of censorship just because that censorship is higher brow.
Give any human the ability to down vote and a reputation number, and comments will automatically converge to some kind of social standard.
HN is mostly filled with people with an interest in tech, finance, and getting rich off tech. That allows for deeper discussions on technical topics and startup finances, but when it comes to politics there's not that much difference between HN and your average subreddit.
Facebook is a "shouting into the void" platform, kind of like Twitter but without the length requirement. In my experience it's never been possible to have any kind of reasonable discussion on there.