I want to make snarky remarks like "What orange site? My top color is some variation of lavender." and post screen shots of it.
I usually resist the urge and try to behave.
Edit: My top color: 9A87AB
It pairs well with the background and text and is easy on my wonky eyes.
(To be clear: I also think I have high quality discussions on HN… but only for certain subjects. Anyone who, for example, advocates for wealth taxes or wealth redistribution or any other positions that wealthy people and people interested in accumulating wealth don’t like often are not given the time of day to intelligently talk about their positions.)
1. my opinions (with respect to technology or politics) have remained the same but their popularity with this site has ebbed and flowed, but relative civility hasn't fluctuated much
2. I can disagree with and be disagreed with civily here, while on Twitter disagreement is almost invariably hostile (yes, you can curate to a small degree)
3. there are people who agree with me on Twitter and Reddit who arrive by the worst conclusions and who are hostile toward people with whom I disagree
I suspect many of the people who hate HN are those who can't disagree civily--who feel like opinions they dislike must be censored or censured.
> This is not about civility but about whether or not the environment is structurally hostile to certain philosophical discussions
It's not hostile to certain philosophical discussions. We've had many robust political and technological debates (including whether the wealthiest should pay more tax and so on), but that doesn't mean the unpopular view carries the day (indeed, my view point on this is probably the unpopular one on this forum, though not by very much).
Now speaking to your concern about which viewpoints get more upvotes, in my experience as a frequent dissenter and devil's advocate, I've found that you can do a lot more on this site to mitigate the unpopularity of your opinions by demonstrating good faith, showing that you understand counterarguments, and communicating clearly. If you make everything hostile and tribal, you're going to have a bad time, which I think is a feature of this site (and which is also very likely the motivation behind so many of the HN=bad types of comments).