Re:Hey CS Paper writers, please show your code
by xyzzyz on Saturday September 24, 2011 @01:52AM
(#3032630)
Your counterpoints are irrelevant. You can obviously attach code to the article, so that there's no need to include any link or other similar thing. If a reviewer wants to do the thing you described, the actual possession of the code is not a big help for him -- what actually keeps him from doing that is honesty, decency and the respect he has among his colleagues he would instantenously lose.
Re:Hey CS Paper writers, please show your code
by pwaring on Saturday September 24, 2011 @05:10AM
(#3032869)
Why not just fill in the link after review but before publication? Presumably that happens with other information which identifies authors, such as their names and email addresses.
Although 'blind' reviewing is something of a misnomer in small research fields where the reviewer can probably guess at least one of the authors.
Re:Hey CS Paper writers, please show your code
by andreasvc on Saturday September 24, 2011 @05:08AM
(#3032866)
Solution: you anonymize the link for peer-review, and only include the real link in the final version. This way the code is not peer-reviewed of course, but peer review can look at the pseudo-code given in the paper.
Your last point really has nothing to do with given away code, nor with peer review: you can plagiarize just about anything. This generally doesn't happen because scientists care a lot about giving credit and recognizing priority.
Additionally there's the risk that the reviewer will reject the paper, and download the code and publish a paper about it quickly in some other journal/conference.