Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits
by kanamekun on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:43PM
(#3032144)
I think Groupon could have been more conservative in how they described their financial statements. However, it's a huge stretch to call them dishonest.
As a commenter put it here: "They were forced into accounting that Priceline hasn't been forced into in 15 years. Accounting that, I might add, provides no real additional visibility into the business. Now, it's a high-margin business with 1/2 the revenue it had before. Then it was a meh margin business with about 2x the revenues. This is not the SEC doing us any favors. It's rearranging chess pieces."
Given the media scrutiny on this, it's clear now that Groupon should have made this adjustment earlier, and referred to their full pass-through revenue as "gross billings" instead of "gross revenue". That would have been the most conservative way to describe their numbers.
Still, it's a big stretch to call this dishonest. It was definitely not conservative labeling. But all the numbers were clearly disclosed, and the labels clearly described. If you read the S-1, it was very clear how their financials worked. The problem is that this is getting so much media attention that people aren't reading the S-1, and are getting their information from the media.
As a commenter put it here: "They were forced into accounting that Priceline hasn't been forced into in 15 years. Accounting that, I might add, provides no real additional visibility into the business. Now, it's a high-margin business with 1/2 the revenue it had before. Then it was a meh margin business with about 2x the revenues. This is not the SEC doing us any favors. It's rearranging chess pieces."
http://allthingsd.com/20110923/more-groupon-amends-its-s-1-i...
Given the media scrutiny on this, it's clear now that Groupon should have made this adjustment earlier, and referred to their full pass-through revenue as "gross billings" instead of "gross revenue". That would have been the most conservative way to describe their numbers.
Still, it's a big stretch to call this dishonest. It was definitely not conservative labeling. But all the numbers were clearly disclosed, and the labels clearly described. If you read the S-1, it was very clear how their financials worked. The problem is that this is getting so much media attention that people aren't reading the S-1, and are getting their information from the media.