News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by danso on Friday September 23, 2011 @07:46PM (#3032031)
Only because this is HN where we're all picky: http://begthequestion.info/
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by cellis on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:01PM (#3032065)
If the phrase is misused 9 times out of 10, then redefine it. That's the hacker way.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by epicureanideal on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:09PM (#3032087)
If we redefine everything based on what 9 out of 10 people do, what will the 1 out of 10 do that are trying to communicate effectively using precise terminology that wait... no longer exists for the concept they're trying to convey.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by shabble on Friday September 23, 2011 @09:58PM (#3032252)
Much as I sympathise with this view, communication isn't about what you say, it's about what the other person hears.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by rhizome on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:43PM (#3032317)
If 9 out of 10 people use it a particular way, it has already been redefined. What we're talking about here is the difference between prescriptive and descriptive linguistics: definition-oriented vs. usage-oriented.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by StavrosK on Saturday September 24, 2011 @11:12AM (#3033382)
If you're telling prescriptivists to stop prescribing, aren't you being a prescriptivist for descriptivism?

Descriptivism lets language evolve. Prescriptivism (people trying to push it back) is part of that evolution. According to your principles, you should just accept it as the way the language evolves.

Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by rhizome on Saturday September 24, 2011 @03:05PM (#3034075)
Prescriptivism provides the foundation for descriptivism's point of departure, and descriptivism provides for the evolution of language. They are part and parcel to each other.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by cellis on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:46PM (#3032150)
Maybe by learning a bit about etymology.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by hugh3 on Saturday September 24, 2011 @10:29AM (#3033288)
What do insects have to do with it?
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by adriand on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:32PM (#3032118)
It won't matter that they can't communicate, since they will have been marginalized as pedants.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by narkee on Saturday September 24, 2011 @12:51AM (#3032555)
This democratization of language isn't necessarily correct. There's a reason why we don't declare the existence of God as truth just because a majority of the population believes it.

There's a reason why majority rules isn't always appropriate. It's because often the majority can be wrong. We won't redefine the answer to the Monty Hall problem just because 9/10 people get the wrong answer.

If we're constantly redefining words and meanings, then why have definitions at all?

Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by megablast on Sunday September 25, 2011 @02:59AM (#3035285)
Language is dynamic, and words do change definition over time.

Having said that, I still prefer to use it correctly.

Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by dasil003 on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:07PM (#3032078)
Also, I can't help but wonder if the fallacy was named based on some colloquialism to begin with.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by abduhl on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:41PM (#3032137)
The fallacy is named because one of the definitions for "beg" is "to evade," which is why "begging the question" can be recast as "evading the question" (although you do lose the subtle part about assuming the conclusion to prove the conclusion).
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by alanh on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:44PM (#3032323)
Thank you. Now I actually learned something from this conversation.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by andreasvc on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:52PM (#3034727)
Yes, it's based on a literal translation of a latin idiom: petitio principo (IIRC). A more unambiguous phrasing is: assuming the antecedent.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by Terretta on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:24PM (#3032101)
On the contrary, nuance matters.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by Pewpewarrows on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:09PM (#3032270)
I never knew there was a difference. Thanks for pointing it out!
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by sid0 on Friday September 23, 2011 @11:40PM (#3032427)
While descriptivists and other such laissez-faire linguists

All linguists are descriptivists.

Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by andreasvc on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:58PM (#3034735)
It's a bit of a silly dichotomy. No linguist will deny that certain sentences are ungrammatical ("cat sees I"), so they are just wrong. And lots of philosophers believe that normativity, what is wrong and right, is an important part of language. But it appears to be something dynamic, language changes over time, yet I can't change language by pretending dog means cat today. So prescriptivism is wrong in the sense that you can't claim to have the sole authority on something. But descriptivism is vacuous, in that it doesn't explain the pervasive tendency for people to consider things to lie on continuum of wrong and right.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by sid0 on Sunday September 25, 2011 @01:17AM (#3035151)
I think your definition of descriptivism is incorrect. Descriptivism certainly doesn't mean everything anyone ever says is gramatically correct. Please read http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/001843.h... .
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by andreasvc on Sunday September 25, 2011 @08:48AM (#3035715)
I offered neither a definition nor a description. Indeed, descriptivism doesn't mean that, and that link is where I got the example from. I was correcting the implicit definition people use when they invoke descriptivism as a cop out from any argument on usage (although I certainly applaud ending any such argument). Descriptivism is a stance for linguists to take in their research, and has nothing to do with the rest of the world.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by sid0 on Sunday September 25, 2011 @09:23AM (#3035758)
Fair enough -- you're correct.

Coming back to the original point (and not in response to you in particular), using "begging the question" to mean "raising the question" is very common now, and trying to object to that does no one any favours.

Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by andreasvc on Sunday September 25, 2011 @03:06PM (#3036481)
That it's common is not sufficient--the majority is not necessarily right. I think pointing out a historical misunderstanding is worthwhile, especially in a forum with smart people or in an academic setting. Using this expression with a meaning based on a misunderstanding reveals that one wants to sound learned without actually being that, so I do think it's a favor to point it out. Of course it's an uphill battle and there's no hope, but I still think there are enough people who do care about where things come from and using them right.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by eli on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:16AM (#3033075)
Some are prescriptivists.
Re:Groupon Restates Revenue, Revenue Fell In Half, COO Exits by sid0 on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:38AM (#3033101)
Standard academic linguistics is by definition descriptive.