Re:Why Good Visualization Matters: Rethinking the Food Label
by calebmpeterson on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:12PM
(#3032277)
> Secondly, these are simple examples. What do you do with, say, a can of chicken and vegetable and noodle soup, which could easily have thirty ingredients before you even start counting the potentially-nasty additives down in a tiny box in the corner.
How about inverting the tree-map such that the smaller the amount, the greater the portion of the tree-map taken up? You're going to need all of that space anyway for the names of those potentially-nasty additives to be printed in a legible font size...
Re:Why Good Visualization Matters: Rethinking the Food Label
by hugh3 on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:38PM
(#3032313)
Ah, the homeopathic approach to food labelling. I'm gonna sprinkle a grain of gold dust on every twinkie I sell, just to screw with the label.
Re:Why Good Visualization Matters: Rethinking the Food Label
by backprojection on Saturday September 24, 2011 @05:03PM
(#3034323)
> Firstly, trace ingredients are often what's important to the consumer. Fine, I know my peanut butter is mostly peanuts, but how much salt is there?
You could put it on a log scale. Probably still confusing to people not familiar with logarithms.
Re:Why Good Visualization Matters: Rethinking the Food Label
by baconner on Friday September 23, 2011 @06:51PM
(#3031887)
I didn't think the #1 entry was very practical either, but the full list of entries is worth a look. There are some good ideas and more realistically usable designs in there. GOOD just isnt likely imo to choose winners based on usefulness over beauty.
Firstly, trace ingredients are often what's important to the consumer. Fine, I know my peanut butter is mostly peanuts, but how much salt is there?
Secondly, these are simple examples. What do you do with, say, a can of chicken and vegetable and noodle soup, which could easily have thirty ingredients before you even start counting the potentially-nasty additives down in a tiny box in the corner.
Thirdly, apparently labellers aren't obliged to split up certain categories (eg broccoli, sugar snap peas, green beans and carrots are all in a single green square). So presumably this doesn't even solve the specified problem of not knowing how much white vs whole wheat is in your food -- why would you split up white and whole wheat into separate categories when beans and carrots are the same?