News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by johnrob on Saturday September 13, 2008 @12:00PM (#303168)
Make something people want. Either people want it or they don't, but I say judge a startup by that and not just technical innovation.
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by swombat on Saturday September 13, 2008 @01:28PM (#303208)
So who wants Yammer? (apart from the VCs)

Do you know anyone who is actually using Yammer?

Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by froo on Saturday September 13, 2008 @04:41PM (#303330)
While Yammer seems an interesting spin on things, I'd much prefer to have this functionality contained within Twitter in the form of private groups - purely from a convenience point of view if anything.

If the Twitter dev team were able to give me everything I wanted, then I'd want the ability to start a private group with people, where updates into that group are protected from my public timeline.

I'd also like the ability to add custom tabs onto my twitter UI so that I could get instant context of any conversation happening within my group, while maintaining the ability for these messages to get forwarded to my mobile device if I wanted.

I would pay for a service like that, absolutely.

Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by sabat on Saturday September 13, 2008 @02:03PM (#303229)
Make something people need. That beats "make something people want" any day of the week. Apologies to PG, but it should be "need". Want is transient; need isn't.
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by JayNeely on Saturday September 13, 2008 @02:26PM (#303241)
Want may be transient, but need is subjective.
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by hooande on Saturday September 13, 2008 @04:54PM (#303341)
It's all fun and games to tell other people to make something targeted at "customers with their hair on fire", but in reality most people's basic needs are met. Are there any "needs" that you have that aren't being satisfied right now? In many cases it's best to make something people want first and get them so used to using it that they really NEED it.

As an example, did anyone really need email before it became ubiquitous? Or was it something that a few people wanted that became an absolute need after it achieved mass adoption?

Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by sabat on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @09:11PM (#306529)
OK, point taken; I need a better word than 'need'. How about "Make something people could really use?" I think this is just all about semantics, really. PG probably means the same thing I do. It's just that "want" evokes javascript solitaire games with emergency fake-spreadheet Boss Buttons. And often, people don't know what they want until you tell them. :-)
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by carpo on Saturday September 13, 2008 @11:30PM (#303566)
People most often buy things they want ahead of what they need, unless it's food and shelter. And even then, they usually want a type of food or shelter that they don't really need, and will buy it even when they can't afford it.
Re:Yammer is TC50 Winner - This is a Joke? Right? by froo on Saturday September 13, 2008 @02:27PM (#303242)
I agree with you on principle, but in today's society (which could be arguably described as hedonistic) people often seem to choose something they want over something they need.