News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Friday February 11, 2022 @04:43PM (#30307362)
> Everything in a book was put there on purpose.

This is nonsense. Having published two novels, I'll say with confidence that a lot of things makes it into books just because it happened to come to mind while you were writing.

Some authors will pay attention to every phrase or every word. Many do not.

This is true even for famous authors - I vividly remember an interview with one who was painted a dramatic picture of symbolism in one of his novels by an interviewer, and then asked about it, and answered that he wished he'd thought of that - he'd just liked how the sentence sounded.

A whole lot of people's interpretations are fine as people's personal head canon, but all to often people project intentions on an author they never had.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by brimble on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:08PM (#30307591)
Several posters seem to have read weird things into the phrase "on purpose". I don't mean that every single word in a book has some grand meaning, but that the author choses to affix some words to the blank page and not others, and then leave them in (or change them) through various editing passes. A novel isn't like a tree in nature where you can just say "it looks that way simply because it does, and that's it—sheer happenstance and natural processes".

For example:

In real life someone goes to the kitchen and makes a sandwich because they're hungry. Sure, good enough.

In a book, an author including a scene in which a character makes a sandwich probably included it for reasons beyond "the character was hungry", even if the reasons are purely structural or for the author's convenience ("I needed them in the kitchen to smell the gas leak") rather than to advance a theme or mood or anything like that. Characters don't have needs, and the degree to which their satisfying normal human needs must be included in a story to maintain suspension of disbelief is typically minimal—so why spend three pages on sandwich making? There should be a reason. If that scene includes two paragraphs on the character's choice of mustard, there should be a reason (even if it's just "I thought it was funny"). That's what I mean.

It's worth interrogating the purpose of the inclusion or exclusion of elements in a book, and the details, because the construction of a book in a certain way is deliberate. That doesn't mean every book stands up to close reading. Sometimes books don't have much going on beyond the surface level (but there are still, guaranteed, reasons behind much of what makes it in, even if they're mundane structural ones—lack of reasons, or bad ones, can amount to mistakes if the included purposeless elements don't, by happenstance, improve the book) but sometimes they really do.

In The Lord of the Flies, there's no island. There are no kids. Golding made them up. Golding didn't put pigs on the island and choose to have the kids notice and then kill a couple them because that was his only option. Even if it had been, he didn't need to devote as much page-space to it as he did. He also wrote in a kid whose nickname is "Piggy", and who features prominently in the book. And there's a whole thing with a pig head on a stick in it. So yes, I think it's totally reasonable to ask "why pigs?" or "what did killing the pig mean?" or all kinds of things along those lines, without any risk whatsoever of disappearing into poorly-supported fancy.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:18PM (#30308185)
After reading this, I stand by what I wrote. There often is no reason other than that it sprung to mind while writing, with no additional intent.

There may well have been in that scene in Lord of the Flies, or not. I don't find it a very interesting question, because absent a statement from the author it's guesswork. And in cases where we do have authors views it is not unusual for it to turn out the guesses were wrong.

And even when there is a purpose it will often be trite or different from what you expect and unrelated to the themes of the story. E. g. a very prominent part at the start of one of my novels, which people might very well think is significant is there just because I found it amusing, with no other significance. I'd concede that counts as purpose, though, if not a purpose anyone would be likely to guess at.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by brimble on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:24PM (#30308235)
Lord of the Flies is plainly allegorical, at least in part. As I (and another poster) noted elsewhere on here, it's made very clear at the end. If you're not going to ask those questions, you may as well not read it.

> After reading this, I stand by what I wrote. There often is no reason other than that it sprung to mind while writing, with no additional intent.

But you kept it in the book. All kinds of things sprung to mind and didn't make it in, surely.

[EDIT] Also:

> I'd concede that counts as purpose, though, if not a purpose anyone would be likely to guess at.

Sure, which is why some books don't reward close reading. Which is fine. But an author's still deciding what goes in and what doesn't, what gets edited out (perhaps with some help) and what stays.

[EDIT EDIT] I don't want to quibble over your writing process or anything, my core point is simply that "there's a whole section about killing pigs because the characters were hungry" would represent poor reading, period. Lack of awareness of structural, character, thematic, allegorical, symbolic, allusive, et c., reasons for choosing to devote page space to one thing over another (or nothing), will make becoming a better reader and writer challenging at best, so it is a good idea to try to teach students those things. Whole kinds of reading would be unapproachable, and even constructing a basic narrative of one's own, unduly difficult. It's possible and sometimes rewarding to ask those sorts of questions about literature because they're not set-in-stone depictions of reality, but something a human constructed. Even documentaries typically exhibit some of these traits, and those intend to depict reality itself in some fashion—editing, shot choices, et c. In a documentary you're not watching someone eat a sandwich, you're watching a specific view of someone eating a sandwich which a human decided to show to you at exactly this point in the film. There's a reason that shot's there and not somewhere else, or some other shot isn't in its place—or there better be, at any rate. So it's likely worth asking why, if only to hone one's own documentary-making skills.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:37AM (#30311056)
> Lord of the Flies is plainly allegorical, at least in part. As I (and another poster) noted elsewhere on here, it's made very clear at the end. If you're not going to ask those questions, you may as well not read it.

This is missing the point, which is not that you can't see meaning and that it's very likely you can guess at the authors intended meaning, but that writing with any kind of certainty about the intent of specific phrases or choices is quickly descending into an experiment in writing fiction.

> But you kept it in the book. All kinds of things sprung to mind and didn't make it in, surely.

Sometimes I kept it in the book because it sprung to mind and fit and there were no reasons to remove it. Sometimes I kept it in the book because it mattered to the plot. Sometimes because it's a fun little joke for my own enjoyment and nobody elses. Sometimes it just fit the pacing but served no other purpose. Sometimes it just sounds cool (in fact, I have a whole file of little fragments I intend to drop into future books when I find somewhere they fit for no other reason than that they sound cool as one-liners or isolated paragraphs). Sometimes because I enjoyed writing it and it's my damn book and I'll put it there if I want to whether or not it serves a purpose.

Maybe, sometime, I'll decide to put in some symbolism (likely not, I have no interest in chasing interpretations of symbolism when reading; I find it trite and conceited and wouldn't want to inflict it on readers with similar views on it as myself, which are ultimately the only readers I particularly care about).

I'm not Golding, and I don't aspire to write work that'll get picked apart in literary reviews. It has no interest to me to even try to hone my skills to Golding's level (and no illusions I'd stand much chance of achieving it). It's a hobby to me, not a life work.

You can well argue that it's different with a writer who appears to have invested a great deal more effort and skill in mastering the craft, and succeeded very well. But the point remains that unless he has spoken to it you don't know whether specific scenes were subject to agonising over phrasing or just sounded right at the time.

Some writers spend ages writing and rewriting. Some churn out a draft and fixes broken sentences and are done. Some spend ages rewriting but only the parts that are important to the plot. Without knowing the specific writers process, and how it was applied for that book, whether or not a given phrase is in there by chance or because it mattered deeply to the author is guesswork.

You can certainly analyse why it works to you as a reader. I have no objections to that. What I object to is the notion that you can say with much certainty why an author placed a given sentence there.

> "there's a whole section about killing pigs because the characters were hungry" would represent poor reading, period.

Would it? It worked, clearly. What the intent of putting it there originally was is entirely irrelevant to your subsequent experience of it. It's quite possible, maybe even likely, that your assumptions about Golding's intent are correct. The point remains that absent any statements from him it still remains a guess. And it's still not very interesting as long as it remains a guess (if Golding has spoken about it, that would be interesting to me). What is interesting is why it works for you as a reader.

I don't think anyone here has suggested you can't (or shouldn't) pick apart why a work is effective for you as a reader.

That is indeed well worth understanding if you want to write, not least because there's often a vast chasm between how writers think they'll be interpreted and how readers will take what they've written and twist it into something unrecognisable and infer all kinds of intent that was never there. You don't need to understand - or try - to avoid that when writing fiction.

On the contrary, writing works that leave lots open to interpretation is a great way of being taken way more seriously than you intended to be.

But understanding what is likely to achieve certain goals or appeal to certain types of readers certainly matters.

And it also matters to those authors, because they certainly do exist, who do have messages they want to convey. Golding certainly seems to want to hit the reader over the head with messages in a very unsubtle way, and so it's not at all unlikely you're right to read things into his choices, but it's still guesswork.

For my part, I have no intent of imparting any deeper message in my own books. I'm just playing with things I find fun, and I know that to be the case for a lot of other writers too, including many substantially better than I am.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by mlyle on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:03PM (#30309536)
> There may well have been in that scene in Lord of the Flies, or not. I don't find it a very interesting question, because absent a statement from the author it's guesswork.

What narrative purposes something serves are absolutely an interesting question-- whether the author intended it or not. And, in quality literature, there's a lot less put there on accident that survives the editing process.

In the end, we can't know anything about intent, but we can figure out a whole lot about what makes the book work, at least for us.

Studying this type of thing makes people into better writers and more astute readers.

I've not read your books, but you have Goodreads reviews indicating that you do a whole lot of telling the reader about your world and things rather than setting up scenes that show them. The bits with pigs in Lord of the Flies are very clear showing, with a combination of literary intent and leaving room for readers' own interpretations.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:30AM (#30311025)
> What narrative purposes something serves are absolutely an interesting question-- whether the author intended it or not.

I have no problem with people discussing what purpose it serves for you. What I have problem with is this frequent notion that you know the intent of the author. Unless they told you.

> And, in quality literature, there's a lot less put there on accident that survives the editing process.

I've witnessed enough discussions with authors to not accept this for a second. It's pure fiction.

> you do a whole lot of telling the reader about your world and things rather than setting up scenes that show them.

I absolutely do, very much on purpose, because I utterly detest this obsession with showing when it comes at the cost of slowing down the story.

I much prefer older style novels that don't make you wade through paragraph after paragraph of descriptions of events that I have no interest in to get to the bits that interests me. I hate books that are afraid of delving into the thought processes of the characters or that are afraid to take shortcuts to describe the why of aspects of the world you can't reasonably show without derailing the story.

I fully accept this is a niche view, and not one that caters to mass appeal, and I'm fine with that.

(In fact, I'll give you one specific story about actual intent: I agonised for a month over feedback from my editor about breaking up the telling in the first chapter of my first novel and rephrasing it to be more "showing", and I specifically decided not to, not because I didn't agree that it'd probably have broader appeal, but because I decided I'd rather put readers that don't like my style off right from the start than lull them into false expectations; that consideration took more time than the rest of the editing combined because setting the right expectations about style from the outset mattered to me far more than any specific sentence)

I'm bothering to tell you this because it clearly does colour my attitude to analysis of literature. I write what I like reading, and I hate it when people try to guess at meanings the author haven't made clear rather than discuss it in terms of what it means to the reader, because I've seen so many utterly ridiculous outcomes of it, but also because I find it dreadfully annoying when writers are coy about their intent and encouraging that.

Now, I don't think Golding was coy in any way, but ironically, when you're being clear about your message, that too tend to egg people into over-interpreting every word to support an interpretation that doesn't need it.

I think the eating of the pig is a good example, because on one hand it's entirely possible, and likely, Golding meant it the way you think. But it is also entirely unnecessary to interpret it that way to understand the book, so it doesn't matter.

You could delete the whole thing, and the rest is still intact. In fact, you could delete most of the book and still get the message, because he keeps hammering you over the head with it - it's not a subtle book (that does make your interpretation more likely; it'd certainly seem to be in keeping with the rest for this to be Golding appearing to hammer us over the head with symbolism, but it's still a guess)

I'd argue that irrespective of the purpose of individual words or paragraphs, most of the book is there not to make the message clear, because the apparent message is trivial and bordering on trite, but to make the book a compelling read. (And yes, that is intentionally reductionist)

> The bits with pigs in Lord of the Flies are very clear showing, with a combination of literary intent and leaving room for readers' own interpretations.

And accordingly inability for you to know the actual intent. That's fine. There's nothing wrong with that. It's the presumption of to what extent you can say anything about the purpose of specific phrasings I take issue with.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by mlyle on Saturday February 12, 2022 @12:40PM (#30314598)
> I have no problem with people discussing what purpose it serves for you. What I have problem with is this frequent notion that you know the intent of the author. Unless they told you.

I think everyone, even dedicated lit crit advocates, know that we can't know what the intent of the author is. But we can see the purpose it serves in the writing, and with a decent author be moderately confident that the important elements here are not complete accidents.

> I've witnessed enough discussions with authors to not accept this for a second. It's pure fiction.

K.

> I absolutely do, very much on purpose, because I utterly detest this obsession with showing when it comes at the cost of slowing down the story.

OK. I don't really like reading massive amounts of exposition drivel, where the author tries to convince me that the world is interesting and makes sense without example.

If I drop in a couple page digression about a character making a sandwich-- why?

- Does the character make the sandwich in the expected way, consistent with the way I, as the author, view them in general?

- Does this fastidious, fussy character carefully arrange his ingredients like I would normally picture him doing so, or does he throw them together?

- If he does something different from how the reader probably pictures them to this point, is it an accident, or am I revealing something about his state of mind or an unexpected other side of his character?

- Do I need some obvious break in the action; some downtime. Do I need to make it clear that the characters are obviously unhurried and open to leisurely talking or exploration next? Do I need to put the characters in some specific place for the next step to happen?

- Did I just run out of things to write that advance the main story, and I'm just doing random things at this point? If I'm taking a digression, or I'm doing something different from what would seem to be in character, I'd hope I'm doing it for a reason.

- Yes, there's still aspects that are totally without purpose. Putting a tomato on the sandwich may not be super meaningful (though it actually does still tell us small things about the world the characters inhabit, and is hopefully still consistent with other things we've been shown/told).

Authors have a whole lot of freedom, but what makes a cohesive story is already a highly constrained sequence of events compared to what could be written on the page. If you want that story to hit with maximum impact, there's yet fewer good choices.

> but also because I find it dreadfully annoying when writers are coy about their intent and encouraging that.

OK, so--- you detest hidden and layered meanings, and assert your writing doesn't have many. That's OK, but assuming that this is representative of most literature isn't valid.

> I'd argue that irrespective of the purpose of individual words or paragraphs, most of the book is there not to make the message clear, because the apparent message is trivial and bordering on trite, but to make the book a compelling read.

For most books, sure! But -why- is it a compelling read? As Chekhov said -- "If you say in the first chapter that there is a rifle hanging on the wall, in the second or third chapter it absolutely must go off. If it's not going to be fired, it shouldn't be hanging there." Every word is a chance to create tension and to play with readers' expectations for what may happen next-- and then fulfill or subvert these expectations. Good literature does this a lot.

This can be a beautiful thing. Reading Mending Wall by Frost, and all of his ambiguity --- wait, does the author like walls or not, and why won't he tell me? Realizing that the first couple sentences were talking about frost not liking a wall was a pure hidden delight. Perhaps this was an accident, but I doubt it... and the meaning's there whether he intended it or not.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Sunday February 13, 2022 @07:30AM (#30321276)
> I think everyone, even dedicated lit crit advocates, know that we can't know what the intent of the author is.

I've personally had discussions with lit crit advocates who argue not only that they can know the intent of the author, but that they can know the intent of the author even when the author contradicts their interpretations.

I'm glad you're not one of them, but they very much do exist, and rejecting the notion that you can know the intent of the author with any reliability was the main point of my original reply.

> But we can see the purpose it serves in the writing, and with a decent author be moderately confident that the important elements here are not complete accidents.

Depends on what you mean by "moderately confident". There are enough cases of authors completely shooting down claims of critics about the meaning of paragraphs that it's clear it's often not at all obvious you can have much confidence in it. (I'd love to see someone try to quantify the accuracy of critics by surveying authors; that'd be fascinating)

Nobody here is objecting to you setting out your theories. My objection was solely to the notion we know the authors intent.

> OK. I don't really like reading massive amounts of exposition drivel, where the author tries to convince me that the world is interesting and makes sense without example.

To me the most interesting parts often are the parts where the author tries to convince me that the world is interesting by telling me about the world. I often find myself skimming past dialogue and descriptions of the characters actions to get to the part that lets me see the world with a birds eye view in exposition because I find the world building and the concept far more interesting than characters that are usually insignificant in the grand scheme of things (and most characters are). I've done that with many fantastic pieces of highly renowned literature because I know it's not the characters I remember once I'm done with a book - often not even the story - but the world and the concepts. Often I find the focus on showing to result in overwrought drivel that is contrived because the author is afraid of just telling us something and need to concoct contrived conversations etc. to show us instead.

We clearly value books for very different reasons. That's fine.

> Authors have a whole lot of freedom, but what makes a cohesive story is already a highly constrained sequence of events compared to what could be written on the page. If you want that story to hit with maximum impact, there's yet fewer good choices.

The problem with this is that you're presuming a specific, fixed story. But absent a statement from the author you have no direct knowledge of the set of possible variations over the story the author might have considered. Some outline in great detail, but that just introduces a step of regression. Others let the story unfold from nothing. For my part, I recursively iterate until I have about 1 line per 1k-2k words. At that point I've somewhat constrained myself, and so there won't be 4000 word digressions, but there sure as hell can be and are multiple paragraphs that I hadn't thought about and that just ends up there without any particular purpose because it felt right when I wrote it.

Back to the point: You won't know whether a given section was a result of that, or was something deeply meaningful to me without asking. You can speculate, and you're of course free to do that.

> OK, so--- you detest hidden and layered meanings, and assert your writing doesn't have many. That's OK, but assuming that this is representative of most literature isn't valid.

This, to me, is an illustration of why you can't presume to know the authors intent, as you here infer an intent behind my words that was not there. It's not strange - I did not elaborate. But it does show how easy it is to think you know the intent behind something and miss it.

To start with, I don't assume that this is representative of most literature. Nowhere did I say it was. That's an inference you made without support in what I wrote. I do assume that given there is a significant number of works for which this is true, and statements where it is true even in works for which it is not for the work as a whole, there is no reliable basis for drawing conclusions about the intent of the author unless they've spoken about it.

That does not mean you can't present possible interpretations and discuss those, of course. The two are entirely orthogonal. It doesn't matter what Golding intended with the pigs as long as it can be read in a given way, to bring it back, and you can discuss to what extent it contributes to the readers interpretation. That remains possible whether or not Golding just happened to be eating bacon when he wrote it or planned it out.

I also did not say that I detest hidden and layered meanings. I said that I find it dreadfully annoying when writers are coy about it and "encouraging [making unsupported guesses]". What I meant was not that there can't be purpose, and layered purpose behind decisions, but I don't like it when it appears the writer is intentionally trying to make it hard to get at the intent of a passage in ways which encourages overwrought interpretations or leave people hanging.

To take a concrete example, in my novels one of the characters have had her eyes replaced by artificial eyes. On purpose. It serves a direct and very overt purpose in the story in that it allows for abilities that are used and directly impacts the plot. As such there's a very obvious surface purpose there. I'll concede that in those cases there's a case to insist people can know my purpose, because there's a direct causal link to the plot.

But for my own part I also liked adding them rather than e.g. giving her wearable tech to achieve the same purpose because I hate wearing glasses and love the idea of being able to use tech to replace the need entirely. So there's a hidden meaning there to me, but not one I've dropped hints about in the text. I don't object to writers doing that at all, as it doesn't affect me as a reader.

If I do feel the urge to reveal that purpose in the text, however, I'll be direct about it rather than drop hints. I won't have her react negatively to someone wearing glasses or talk about how annoying it must be, or otherwise be coy about it by implying there's another layer to that choice but leave the reader hanging. I'll have her give someone that as reason for having made her change. I might well do that at some point. I fully get that some people love it when the writing is all mysterious and the writer isn't giving up their secrets. For my part I find that just about as annoying as if they'd ended a book on a cliffhanger. I want to dive into the reasons and what lies beneath them, not be stuck speculating because the author refuses to tell me after they've teased it by dropping hints. If you prefer the mystery that's fine, that's your choice. To me it feels lazy - you avoid having to find ways of giving an answer without it being contrived or disappointing. This does also tend to make me dislike symbolism embedded in works that are external to the work and can't really be revealed "in world" because it feels gratuitous.

> For most books, sure! But -why- is it a compelling read?

The why is separate from the writers intent. So we're back to my purpose with my initial response on this thread: I don't object to people exploring why it's a compelling read at all. On the contrary. What I object to is the idea you know the authors intent. By all means, explore why it's a compelling read.

> As Chekhov said -- "If you say in the first chapter that there is a rifle hanging on the wall, in the second or third chapter it absolutely must go off. If it's not going to be fired, it shouldn't be hanging there." Every word is a chance to create tension and to play with readers' expectations for what may happen next-- and then fulfill or subvert these expectations. Good literature does this a lot.

I find it fascinating that you first give this Chekov quote here and then argue for subverting expectations after a quote that tells you explicitly to excluding objects unless you're prepared to meet the expectations their presence creates. For my part, I strongly disagree with Chekov there. I get the why - it creates a strong focus on the story. If you want that, then it's the right thing to do. But to me it leaves the resulting worlds cold and barren in a way that strips it of interest to me. I want to know about all of the details that do not matter to the story but tells me about the world and creates an atmosphere. A book where a rifle on the wall means it will be used, to me is one stripped of wonder and mystery.

> This can be a beautiful thing. Reading Mending Wall by Frost, and all of his ambiguity --- wait, does the author like walls or not, and why won't he tell me? Realizing that the first couple sentences were talking about frost not liking a wall was a pure hidden delight. Perhaps this was an accident, but I doubt it... and the meaning's there whether he intended it or not.

You don't need to know or claim to know the writers intent to be able to take delight in that. You're free to imagine whatever interpretation you choose. I'm not arguing you shouldn't. I'm arguing against assuming you know the writers intent, and only that. I used to write a lot of poetry, and more than once ended up in arguments with people who claimed to have found some hidden meaning I'd supposedly inserted. I had to explain to them that I had no objections to them finding those meanings in it, but those were not mine, they were theirs. That's not at all to say that others don't insert all kinds of hidden meanings in what they write, but I would not presume to know, that's all.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:34PM (#30309084)
> a lot of things makes it into books just because it happened to come to mind while you were writing.

Can’t you ask yourself why this is what came to mind, and why you kept it on in later drafts? It seems like the same question. Said differently, it’s asking why this part works, rather than why you wrote it, right?

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vidarh on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:22AM (#30310987)
I could, I do, and often there's just no basis for looking for a deeper meaning other than that it happens to work, or that you need more words to not make things sound too rushed for example. You might as well ask a Markov chain why it produced the outcome it did, because sometimes the process of writing those specific words is no more guided by anything meaningful than that.

This of course does not hold for everything. Some parts are essential plot elements. Some writers in some works absolutely do pound you over the head with symbolism on purpose, or layer in things you might never notice. But that doesn't mean everything in a book has a message or a purpose other than to read well. Some things are just filler.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday February 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#30314417)
Oh yeah i totally agree. I wish there was more emphasis in these circles on “for pacing” rather than “for social commentary” because that kind of reason is just as interesting, if not more interesting, and it’s more likely to actually be the reason that sentence is there.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by stjohnswarts on Friday February 11, 2022 @09:22PM (#30309332)
I agree, having written some short stories and novellas. Sometimes it really is just dinner and the conversation is what it is. There doesn't necessarily have to be structurally purposeful meaning or metaphor in every paragraph. Not every work of fiction is Ulysses.