Re:Don't trust comments
by naruhodo on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:13AM
(#30297686)
> I like the Corvette, but
You don't like the Corvette. Not that Corvette. However, you like Corvettes in general. Or you only like red Corvettes.
> I like steak, but
Turn the comma into a period: I like steak. It's unconditional; steak is a big yes for you. Except it's not. You have conditions. So sometimes you like steak and sometimes the opposite. You don't like steak.
I think the interpretation of but is not as trivially stupid as you say.
You don't like the Corvette. Not that Corvette. However, you like Corvettes in general. Or you only like red Corvettes.
> I like steak, but
Turn the comma into a period: I like steak. It's unconditional; steak is a big yes for you. Except it's not. You have conditions. So sometimes you like steak and sometimes the opposite. You don't like steak.
I think the interpretation of but is not as trivially stupid as you say.