News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I changed my mind about advertising by londons_explore on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:36AM (#30286570)
In a perfect market economy, those two lists are equal.

Thats because the company who produces the product you are most interested in can afford to spend the most on ads. Products you aren't very interested in, either because they cost too much, or aren't up to your standards, you are unlikely to buy, and therefore those manufacturers won't be able to afford to get to the top ad spot.

In reality, this doesn't work because the market is far from perfect, and the amount of margin a company has on a product to spend on advertising widely varies.

Re:I changed my mind about advertising by wpietri on Thursday February 10, 2022 @10:09AM (#30287137)
"Perfect market" is a technical term meaning one where "buyers and sellers are so numerous and well informed that monopoly is absent and market prices cannot be manipulated". A perfect market would not help this problem.

The notion that perfect realizations of Econ 101 concepts would produce outcomes everybody likes it both wrong and quasi-religious. It's like saying, "The perfect knife would never cut a human." Nope.

If anything, the whole purpose of advertising is to create market distortions. Look at Coke vs Pepsi, for example. Billions are spent yearly to manipulate consumers to make choices that differ from whatever the natural marketplace outcome would be.

Re:I changed my mind about advertising by hnaccount141 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @10:29AM (#30287501)
What's more, even in a perfect market as you describe, advertising will only ever represent the subset of the solution space for any given problem that involves spending money. With how powerful a voice advertising has, we end up training people to deal with problems by buying rather than doing/learning/making.

In a perfect market, the top ad would be for the best treadmill. You'd never see an ad for just going outside for a run.

Re:I changed my mind about advertising by londons_explore on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:04PM (#30291693)
In a totally perfect market, the park charges runners a few cents to go for a run, and spends some of that revenue on advertising the park to runners, and then they would outcompete treadmill ads (for some users).

The reason you don't see this is because free parks are themselves a market distortion.