News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did HAL Commit Murder? by JKCalhoun on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @06:52PM (#30280546)
Sadly, the astronauts were no different to HAL than the opposing chess pieces when he plays chess against Frank Poole.

When they became a threat to the mission they were discarded.

Cold logic. Murder is like "sin", something we ascribe to malice, against God. What HAL did is just as horrible, but perhaps not "murder"?

The article introduced me to the idea of mens rea. I take it there may come a time when a machine moves beyond cold logic and we might have to call a similar act murder.

Interesting Clarke suggesting it was perhaps a conflict within HAL to both conceal the mission from the two conscious astronauts and trying to be truthful.

Re:Did HAL Commit Murder? by kadoban on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @07:29PM (#30280863)
> The article introduced me to the idea of mens rea. I take it there may come a time when a machine moves beyond cold logic and we might have to call a similar act murder.

If a human uses cold logic to decide to kill someone, is that murder? Why not if a machine does it then?