We're literally discussing the causative relationship between a specific economic system, with specific foundations and philosophies, and moral and social progression, not the existence of amalgamous profit motive and how it was exercised in various social, political, and economic systems. Your point is entirely irrelevant to the discussion at hand. Profit motive is not capitalism. Mercantilism is not capitalism. Trade is not capitalism. Feudalism is not capitalism. I know anti capitalists like to label anything that has profit anywhere in it as capitalism but that's intellectually dishonest and completely outside accepted economic history and philosophy. Slavery isn't practiced in societies where it is morally and ethically opposed. If profit was the prerequisite for slavery, and not dehumanization, then it would persist regardless of morality. Profit seeking via slavery is entirely contingent on dehumanization. Capitalist societies are the only ones in human history that have enduring humanization of everyone, and that's not a coincidence.
>George Fitzhugh quote
You seem very adamant about raising points that have nothing to do with the assertions I've made. However, since we're copying and pasting out of context quotes from Wikipedia instead of actually reading or even attempting to read Sociology for the South, Cannibals All!, speech transcripts, or anything contextually, here's some quotes, including from the same subsection you copied and pasted from, that illustrate his sometimes paradoxical views on socialism, and my primary point, that his stance was based on anything that humanized black people, and argumentation shared by many in this thread against capitalism:
"We entirely agree with the socialists, that free competition is the bane of modern society. We also agree with them, that it is right and necessary to establish in some modified degree, a community of property. We agree with them in the end they propose to attain, and only differ as to the means.[...] What madness and folly, at this late day, to form society for human beings regardless of human nature. Yet the Socialists are guilty of this folly, and gravely propose to change man's nature to fit him for their new institutions. How much more wise, prudent and philosophical it would be to recur to some old tried forms of society, especially as we shall presently show that such forms of society have existed, and do now exist, as will remove all the evils they complain of, and attain all the ends they propose."
"No association, no efficient combination of labor can be effected till men give up their liberty of action and subject themselves to a common despotic head or ruler. This is slavery, and towards this socialism is moving."
"The Abolitionists and Socialists, who, alone have explored the recesses of social science, well understand that they can never establish their Utopia until private property is abolished or equalized. The man without property is theoretically, and, too often, practically, without a single right."
"Liberty is an evil which government is intended to correct. This is the sole object of government.“
"The great object of government is to restrict, control and punish man ‘in the pursuit of happiness'."
"Socialism, with such despotic head, approaches very near to Southern slavery, and gets along very well so long as the despot lives."
"Free trade or political economy is the science of free society, and socialism is the science of slavery."
"Property is not a natural and divine, but conventional right; it is the mere creature of society and law… if private property generally were so used to injure, instead of promote public good, then society might and ought to destroy the whole institution."
"Slavery is a form of communism… The manner to which the change shall be made from the present form of society to that system of communism which we propose is very simple."
"The bestowing upon men equality of rights, is but giving license to the strong to oppress the weak. It begets the grossest inequalities of condition."
"Slavery relieves our slaves of these cares altogether, and slavery is a form, and the very best form, of socialism."
"Private property destroys liberty and equality."
"The failure of laissez-faire, of political economy, is admitted now by its last and lingering votary. Free society stands condemned by the unanimous testimony of all its enlightened members."
"Our only quarrel with Socialism is, that it will not honestly admit that it owes its recent revival to the failure of universal liberty, and is seeking to bring about slavery again in some form."
"None but lawyers and historians are aware how much of truth, justice and good sense, there is in the notions of the Communists, as to the community of property. Laying no stress on the too abstract proposition that Providence gave the world not to one man, or set of men, but to all mankind, it is a fact that all governments, in civilized countries, recognize the obligation to support the poor, and thus, in some degree, make all property a common possession."
Hopefully this is sufficient to illustrate that your copying and pasting of Wikipedia, whose editors have done a great job of curating his article to support their overwhelming political leanings, was very foolish and short-sighted. Read the books before you attempt to use them authoritatively.
>You're not contradicting me. We can only have rights and freedoms by collectively agreeing where those limits are, and enforcing them as a society. That's what laws and regulations do.
No, those freedoms and rights exist regardless of whether or not a society does. It's only the imposition of society or others that attempts to take those things away. You don't magically get rights because of society.
No, I raised a point that countered your claim that Fitzhugh opposed capitalism because it was closely coupled with the abolition. He opposed socialism just as much. Neither of your quotes negate that, which I think illustrates the further point that he's an unreliable narrator.
> Profit motive is not capitalism. Mercantilism is not capitalism. Trade is not capitalism. Feudalism is not capitalism.
May I ask, what is capitalism, to you?
> I know anti capitalists like to label anything that has profit anywhere in it as capitalism but that's intellectually dishonest and completely outside accepted economic history and philosophy.
I'm not anti-capitalist, I'm anti-"one tool for all jobs" and equally simplistic views.
> Slavery isn't practiced in societies where it is morally and ethically opposed.
Sure.
> If profit was the prerequisite for slavery, and not dehumanization, then it would persist regardless of morality.
This absolutely does not follow any chain of logic. There can be more prerequisites than one, and morality can supersede something else.
> Profit seeking via slavery is entirely contingent on dehumanization.
Sure.
> Capitalist societies are the only ones in human history that have enduring humanization of everyone, and that's not a coincidence.
Again, which capitalist societies? The US is a mixed economy, as is every other country in the western world. They are functioning because they have a better or worse enforced playing field and infrastructure, and yes, social programs.
> No, those freedoms and rights exist regardless of whether or not a society does. It's only the imposition of society or others that attempts to take those things away. You don't magically get rights because of society.
But you literally just said:
> We're literally discussing the causative relationship between a specific economic system, with specific foundations and philosophies, and moral and social progression, not the existence of amalgamous profit motive and how it was exercised in various social, political, and economic systems.
So either it existed before society or it didn't? Pick one, you can't have both.
Instead of asking me to read books you've picked out in a Gish Gallop, maybe you use the knowledge you learned from them and explain what capitalism is, when it came into existence, and which societies you believe embodies its principles.
There's no such thing as capitalism to me. The things I listed are demonstrably not capitalism
>So either it existed before society or it didn't? Pick one, you can't have both
Pick one of what? Rights exist independent of society. Society and government trampled on them for most of history. Some guys that led a revolution wrote a lot about this and the self evident nature.
As for your last request, I've done that repeatedly and you've repeatedly resorted to attempts to change the topic.
Capitalism and its principles, capitalist societies, and capitalist philosophers have consistently demonstrated the most rapid and prolific advances in ethics and morality in human history.
I'm asking you specific questions. You are asking me to read books you have dictated, regardless of if I've read them or not. I'm asking about your interpretation, and you repeatedly ignore that simple, basic, foundational component of a discussion. I'm inclined to disagree what constitutes bad faith.
> There's no such thing as capitalism to me. The things I listed are demonstrably not capitalism
So is capitalism everything you haven't listed? Is the question too broad or difficult?
> Pick one of what? Rights exist independent of society. Society and government trampled on them for most of history. Some guys that led a revolution wrote a lot about this and the self evident nature.
Pre-society your rights went as far as you could throw a rock and defend yourself, or your tribe enforced it. You can call rights inherent all you want, but in practice the enforcability is the only thing that matters. Without society person A can walk into person B's house while they're sleeping and remove person A and now there's a new house owner. The rights and freedoms you describe require that we agree what constitutes those rights, so that we can agree on how they're enforced, through police and courts, through elections, and what rights you have to move from point A to point B, given that without this framework you could get landlocked by others ownership.
> As for your last request, I've done that repeatedly and you've repeatedly resorted to attempts to change the topic.
It would be easier to just copy and paste it than to write something else. You haven't though, or I wouldn't have asked. Please argue in good faith.
> Capitalism and its principles...
Which you won't define
> capitalist societies...
which you won't specify
> and capitalist philosophers have consistently demonstrated the most rapid and prolific advances in ethics and morality in human history.
Easy to claim if you don't have to substantiate it.
If you don't want to discuss the topic, and only deflect everything through vague references elsewhere, then what point is there in you posting?
Darwinism predates "Darwinism". Yours is not an argument.
People traded before states existed.
Rational actors didn't appear at the date when the model description of capitalism was defined. People kept slaves because they could (obviously). We can argue that they either did this for profit or for laughs. I know what I'd bet.
> You should also read George Fitzhugh, the most prominent representative of anti abolitionist plantation owners. He was a staunch anti-capitalist specifically because the moral framework it is built on humanized black people and this sentiment was a primary driver in the abolitionist movement. Capitalists and abolitionists were extremely closely associated during the abolitionist movement.
"We treat the Abolitionists and Socialists as identical, because they are notoriously the same people, employing the same arguments and bent on the same schemes. Abolition is the first step in Socialism: the former proposes to abolish negro slavery, the latter all kinds of slavery - religion, government, marriage, families, property - nay, human nature itself. Yet the former contains the germ of the latter, and very soon ripens into it; Abolition is Socialism in its infancy." - George Fitzhugh
> > Maximizing rights and freedoms on the macro scale means limiting some people's edge freedoms on the micro scale.
> No it doesn't. It means preventing others from stepping on universal freedoms of others, which is exactly the philosophical foundations of private property.
Meaning someone enforces your right to property from someone else having a different idea of freedoms.
You're not contradicting me. We can only have rights and freedoms by collectively agreeing where those limits are, and enforcing them as a society. That's what laws and regulations do.