News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Friday February 11, 2022 @04:41PM (#30307352)
We've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines. You can't post like this here, regardless of how right you are or feel you are.

Also: we ban accounts that use HN primarily for ideological battle, regardless of what they're battling for or against. It's not what this site is for, it destroys what it is for, and I had to ask you about this already.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:47PM (#30308418)
Others are free to make inflammatory ideological and political points, as long as they conform to liberalism.

It’s your website, but history will not judge you kindly.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:51PM (#30309162)
No, we don't care if someone is "conforming to liberalism", we care whether they're conforming to the HN guidelines. It's common for people to think that we're secretly siding with their opponents when we do this kind of moderation (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...), but that sort of perception isn't based in fact.
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:48AM (#30311453)
Liberalism is the root of this obsession with civility, while our countries get bombed and pillaged. If you ban polemics, you side with the dominant ideology.

As before, you compare similar handling of centre-left and far right politics. Good luck with that.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Saturday February 12, 2022 @02:14PM (#30315409)
We stopped using the word civility many years ago already, because it doesn't communicate the values we care about here.

> If you ban polemics, you side with the dominant ideology.

There's a strong version and a weak version of that argument. Using it to justify garden-variety internet swipes like "only Americans and children could believe such an absurd statement" is the weak version, and not very persuasive.

Thoughtful critique is welcome here, and curious conversation between people who respect each other and listen to each other is hardly a 'dominant ideology'. The problem is that a lot of us (all of us, most likely) use noble concepts to justify treating others badly.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:07AM (#30320672)
Doesn’t really matter what you call it, the end result is about the same: polite thoughtful conversation on whether Chinese Americans should be interned or whether Eastern Europe should be invaded by NATO or even just whether exploiting workers is acceptable. It used to be about whether my Serbian neighbours should be bombed, but on previous forums.

Swipes at Americans are useful, it can make them wonder why their country is so hated across the world. It can also be useful as part of a wider polemic to re-focus on the real contradiction: imperialists versus the rest of us.

Your rules as enforced absolutely reinforce imperialism, regardless of your intentions. Again, it’s your website. I’m not going to convince you, just trying to explain to you what you’re doing.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:51AM (#30323120)
Swipes do not make people "wonder why they are so hated". They just make them hate back. That is not useful.

If you want to actually be heard, you need to communicate in a way that works for the other.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:51PM (#30326850)
Being reasonable is often not effective. It’s like asking workers to communicate in a way that works for the capitalists’ police, as they get shot. Most Americans will choose fascism anyway, the only point is to get the rest to see it. Aggression is far more effective at that.

It’s not surprising you’d side with the empire, your material interests align with it. Y combinator is after all part of the export of capital at usury rates. It’s ok, when our turn comes we will make no excuses either.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:34AM (#30272418)
It's an objective historical fact.

The overwhelming majority of ethical and moral progression in human history coincided with the extension of private property rights to more and more of the general population, and retracted when those rights were rescinded.

This occurred both because of the recognition of humanity that goes along with granting these rights, and the technological progressions enabled by allowing opportunity and innovation to occur in larger swaths of the population rather than an aristocratic hyperminority.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:28AM (#30272990)
You're just describing class struggle and industry, not capitalism specifically.

Capitalism was once revolutionary against feudalism, as the bourgeoisie replaced the nobility as the ruling class. But that hasn't been the case for centuries.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#30273028)
No I'm not. I'm very specifically describing the economic, ethical, and moral foundations upon which capitalism is built and the effects it has on economic and social progression. Effects that have been observed and consistent across numerous nations transitioning from numerous economic and social systems to and from capitalism.

Regurgitating Marx isn't going to be effective against someone who has a more holistic understanding of capitalism and its roots. Funny given your accusations of "Americans and children" considering Marx was a literal man child.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by cloudfifty on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:21AM (#30274475)
> considering Marx was a literal man child

I must ask. Why, according to you, was he a "literal man child"?

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:41PM (#30275513)
[dead]
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:25PM (#30277982)
Cool, what does that have to do with the verifiable facts about who he was as a person and the role they played in his writings and philosophy?
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by lucian1900 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:48AM (#30273204)
You're conflating the ideology capitalism uses to justify and maintain itself with its actual material reality. It's not a surprise, considering this ideology (liberalism) is fundamentally idealist and not materialist.

Have you actually read Marx or Engels? You'll find a holistic understanding of capitalism and its roots, its upsides and its downsides.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by cloudfifty on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#30273034)
> The overwhelming majority of ethical and moral progression in human history coincided with the extension of private property rights to more and more of the general population, and retracted when those rights were rescinded.

Why is it always the "objective facts" brand of capitalist activists that can immediately after do an extraordinary subjective - and biased - interpretation of a weak historical correlation?

That's just blatant historical revisionism, with clearly no attempt made whatsoever to try to disprove your own claim. You'll have to surgically remove at least 80% of Capitalism's history for it to be even close to true. Even then, you have many societies in "human history" that certainly would argue that their "ethical and moral" progression was significantly better than today's.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:24PM (#30275276)
>Why is it always the "objective facts" brand of capitalist activists that can immediately after do an extraordinary subjective - and biased - interpretation of a weak historical correlation?

It's consistent across time and the globe for the overwhelming majority of nations transitioning to and from capitalism to any other system. It's not just some singular event that happened once in the 18th century, it's observable right now. I provided examples in another comment.

>You'll have to surgically remove at least 80% of Capitalism's history for it to be even close to true.

Prove it. What is this 80%?

>Even then, you have many societies in "human history" that certainly would argue that their "ethical and moral" progression was significantly better than today's.

Name them and describe how and why.

Why is it always those that insist on ignoring objective historical facts can never substantiate their assertions and rather make axiomatic statements?

I provided explicit examples and illustrated consistency across time and geography. Hand wavy dismissals aren't doing your argument any favors.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by cloudfifty on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:09PM (#30275932)
> It's consistent across time and the globe for the overwhelming majority of nations transitioning to and from capitalism to any other system. It's not just some singular event that happened once in the 18th century, it's observable right now. I provided examples in another comment.

Not really, Capitalism have also been observed to do its thing without democracy as well. And just moving forward is a pretty low bar, the USSR had lots of progress as well, but it doesn't make Stalinism a good system. It's also fundamentally a correlation, not causation. Would another historical path had a better outcome for the average citizen? Maybe, maybe not.

> Prove it. What is this 80%?

Slavery? Racism? Colonialism? Property requirements to vote? Women suffrage? Supporting brutal regimes in the name of corporate profit? Famine while still exporting? Exploitation fueled by Capitalism's profit and growth motive? Climate and ecological disaster? People dying in the US due to lack of healthcare access? etc...

> Name them and describe how and why.

Come on, you're the one preaching, it's your duty to prove your extraordinary claim against history. Capitalism is like 400 years old. A mere blip. Native American's societies for example thought of people being forced to wage labour their entire life for someones else's enrichment to be not much better than being a slave. Certainly not "freedom" in any case. Not to even mention their thoughts about the concept of private ownership of the commons, as in private property.

> I provided explicit examples and illustrated consistency across time and geography. Hand wavy dismissals aren't doing your argument any favors.

What explicit examples?

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:27PM (#30278019)
>Not really, Capitalism have also been observed to do its thing without democracy as well

Prove it

> the USSR had lots of progress as well, but it doesn't make Stalinism a good system

Not morally or ethically, which I'll remind you, yet again is what we're talking about. Stay on topic

>Slavery? Racism? Colonialism? Property requirements to vote? Women suffrage? Supporting brutal regimes in the name of corporate profit? Famine while still exporting? Exploitation fueled by Capitalism's profit and growth motive? Climate and ecological disaster? People dying in the US due to lack of healthcare access?

Prove the causative relationship between these things and capitalism, and that they make up 80% of capitalism's history, your original assertion. Why did they exist before capitalism?

Why did many of these good things fail to happen before capitalism? Why do they happen virtually everywhere afterwards?

Capitalist countries are the most ecologically and climate efficient per capita and quality of life.

Exploitative compared to what and where?

Examine severe illness outcomes, pharmaceutical research, medical innovation, and general health of the US (meaning, US citizens have bad health habits) vs elsewhere before you make such ignorant comments.

>Come on, you're the one preaching, it's your duty to prove your extraordinary claim against history. Capitalism is like 400 years old.

Which is why it's remarkable how much progress has occurred under it in such a short period of time, literally my point

>Native American's societies for example thought of people being forced to wage labour their entire life for someones else's enrichment to be not much better than being a slave. Certainly not "freedom" in any case. Not to even mention their thoughts about the concept of private ownership of the commons, as in private property.

You continually speak authoritatively about subjects you clearly do not have any insight into. Native Americans practiced slavery & conquest. Native Americans had private property. They also hadn't invented the wheel and sacrificed hundreds of thousands of people a year on top of pyramids. You're regurgitating well known popular myths. Stop deviating off topic

>What explicit examples?

China under Pooh's new crackdown on private property and capitalist tendencies vs it when it opened and extended private property rights. Estonia post-USSR. Zimbabwe vs Botswana. Just a few, modern ones, if we want to go back to the 18th and 19th century the trend was nearly universal in the west.

[dead]
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by defaultprimate on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @06:37PM (#30280384)
>Hahaha! You have to be joking?

Which modern, high quality of life, non capitalist countries are less harmful to the environment?

>You have no scruples at all do you? "No insight into" then you go on avoiding the point and just falsely suggesting that I said something I didn't say (treating all historical North American societies as one, which is ridiculous), what a deeply dishonest thing to write, shame on you.

What was your point then? You were leveraging some native American sentiments and factually incorrect popular myths on their beliefs about property ownership to contend falsely that they had better economic systems devoid of profit motive or property.

>I won't be wasting energy on replies that have zero prospect of breaking through that dogma. I can see others have tried with no success.

The irony coming from someone with entirely unsourced, repeatedly demonstrably false assertions, while I have provided endless examples and sources.

Sorry, not sorry for sticking to my well researched and verbosely sources principles and reasoning because random strangers on the internet regurgitate easily countered dogma from ideologues and propagandists.

I can tell you exactly what evidence would look like that would change my mind about any topic I hold strong beliefs about. Meanwhile you can't even stick to one topic.

[dead]
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Friday February 11, 2022 @04:28PM (#30307199)
Your account has been using HN primarily for ideological battle. That's against the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) and we ban such accounts regardless of what they're battling for or against. I've therefore banned this one. If you or anyone want further explanation, see these links:

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by cloudfifty on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:25PM (#30307746)
What a sad state of affairs when pushing back against the bullshit spread by the very prolific reactionaries, albeit polite (which is all that matters here), of this site sooner or later gets one banned. To add insult to injury most of them have been posting on HN for many years.
Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:55PM (#30309179)
I don't know what you're referring to, but if there are accounts breaking the HN guidelines the way you were doing, which we haven't banned yet, I'd like to know which ones they are.

Everyone thinks that we're secretly siding with their opponents when we do this kind of moderation (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...), but that feeling is not based in fact. It's just an inversion of your own sympathies. The other side thinks we're ruining the site by secretly siding with you.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by cloudfifty on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:24AM (#30311331)
You alone can't do anything about the demographics and their biases here. Buy if you honestly believe that HN is somehow politically neutral you're deluded.

It does't require a sociologist to realise that when certain topics degenerates into 500-1000 comments of bullshit and others doesn't even register that this user base has a certain bias.

Finally, what is seen as ideological warfare naturally follows the overton window. I could directly translate liberal/conservative folks posts here into a equivalent socialist narrative instead and it would be seen as ideological warfare because it's simply out of the ordinary.

You can just look through my comment history and the users I've replied to if you're genuinely interested.

Re:Texas power crisis revealed flaw in market’s design by dang on Saturday February 12, 2022 @02:21PM (#30315467)
Actually I'm not making any argument or claim about political neutrality, and I don't think I've ever made such a claim. That would be a difficult thing to study, if it's even possible.

I'm making an empirical observation about how people with strong political passions react when they get moderated, and the rather obvious root of those reactions. The fact that people of all ideologies and political types react with exactly the same reflex is relevant because it clarifies that root so vividly.