News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by feral on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:33PM (#3026630)
I don't think what you are talking about is arbitrage, either.

You are talking about using interest free loans from credit cards in order to make a leveraged bet on the price of gold; that is not arbitrage.

If gold decreases in price - and its close to record highs, however you want to intrepret that - you are taking a huge risk.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by bluena on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:41PM (#3026664)
agreed. buying gold is risky. instead puting it in a 2% account would be wiser.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by typicalrunt on Thursday September 22, 2011 @01:37PM (#3026895)
However, once you factor in inflation -- which runs at or around 2% depending on the country you live in -- you are making no money at the end of the year.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by 2arrs2ells on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:26PM (#3027116)
No, as a borrower, inflation works to your advantage.

i.e. I borrow $1k at 0% for one year. I put the money in a 1 year CD paying 1% interest. At the end of the year, I pay back the loan with the CD's principal, and put the $10 interest in my pocket.

Even if inflation were 2% (or 10%, or 100%), I am still making money - no matter how deflated the value of the dollar is, I still have more dollars in my pocket than when I started.

(Inflation hurts lenders of money, not borrowers)

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:45PM (#3026683)
I covered the idea of putting the money into a CD in my comment. Even if you get a CD that returns %6, you'd need $400k in debt to raise the $20k.

Maybe mentioning gold is "politically incorrect" and so I'm getting down votes and disagreement, when the gist of my comment was talking about different ways you could arbitrage to raise money for a startup.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by justincormack on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:12PM (#3027816)
No you are talking about different ways you could speculate to fund a startup. Thats not arbitrage.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:10AM (#3028908)
If you provided a counter argument, I could respect that. Instead you're lying about what I've said, and that's worse than useless.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by fuzzythinker on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:46PM (#3026690)
Not to mention that he seemed to forget about the 3.5% or so transaction fee that is usually associated with the 0% loans. This makes most safe investments like CDs in today's rates a negative return.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Thursday September 22, 2011 @01:02PM (#3026752)
I mentioned CDs in my article. Did you stop reading at the first mention of gold? Further, CDs are not a "safe investment" because the real rate of inflation (not CPI, but actual monetary inflation) is greater than the return of the CD, by quite a lot. Another risk of CDs is that the bank might fail. Since the FDIC hasn't been collecting reasonable premiums against this risk, and banks are failing left and right, the deficit is made up via inflation, which means, you get paid back in lower value dollars than you lost.

This is also what makes gold a relevant possibility for this type of arbitrage. Since gold's supply is relatively fixed, as the dollar declines due to inflation, the gold price will appreciate. So, even if there were no increasing interest in gold from investors (e.g.: no appreciation due to increased demand) you'd be arbitraging the delta between the exchange rates of the two currencies. Borrowing in dollars and buying gold.

This could be, as I mentioned, done between any two currencies. Or, in the case of CDs, which I mentioned in my original comment, within the same currency.

But I guess that since I mentioned gold it is Very Important for you lot to say that gold is risky, and that I'm obviously falling to "mention" those things that I, uh, er, mentioned.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by wisty on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:12PM (#3028027)
Once again, you say:

> Since gold's supply is relatively fixed, as the dollar declines due to inflation, the gold price will appreciate.

You are assuming that gold is "safe". It's not. If gold dives right when you need to pay back the card, you will start paying massive rates on the card. Not cool. Not even gold bugs suggest gold is a safe "no brainer" 6 month investment - there is a chance it will fall.

Big call - that gold will appreciate. Some people think that since the P/E of gold is effectively infinite, gold should be worth essentially nothing. Now, I'm fairly bullish on gold at the moment, but it's not guaranteed to appreciate. As credit collapses, cold hard cash becomes valuable, as you need it to buy the distressed assets of former paper-millionaires, or to invest in a much less congested market, or buy old tires to repair the soles of your kids shoes, so you actually go into deflation. And the US can sell off gold reserves if it gets in trouble (though there are conspiracy theorists who say this has already happened), and that would hurt gold prices.

If you get $10,000 from zero-interest credit cards, and put it a 6 month term 2% / year deposit, you debt is $10,000 (really $9,000 after massive inflation), while you get back $10,100 (really $9,090). So you made $100 (really $90, with some crazy inflation sucking up your winnings). A free $100 is arbitrage.

And old (and very similar) scheme was "Check kiting" - you cash a check (possibly for a very large amount), then deposit the money in your savings account (or use it as an emergency loan). Before the first check clears, you cash another check, and use it to cover the first one. If you miss a beat, you go to jail.

Instead of arbitraging the interest rates, you could make a leveraged bet on gold, houses (they always go up, because they 'aint makin' any more land, you know, and the population keeps increasing), shares, options, pork bellies, or cans of sardines. But the danger is, that some wacky market dynamic will wipe out your position, leaving you with a credit card debt you can't repay. Maybe you are a great investor, and know how to pick winners (and cover your downside) but great investors don't often need to borrow a few thousand off a credit card.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by fuzzythinker on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:47PM (#3027489)
Hmm, not sure why you and others respond so negatively on my comment. I am merely pointing out that your original reply did not account for the usual 3-3.5% transaction fee on these 0% loans. Your only mention of such fee may be the "could borrow at %1 (on the "zero interest" plans)", which isn't anywhere close the 3-3.5% that I see. So taking that into account, "safe" investments like CDs will actually give negative return.

Meta: Not only did I read your whole initial parent post, I had also not mentioned a single word about "gold". So I am really intrigued by your negative tone and accusation of me jumping on the "anti-gold argument" bandwangon. Btw, I really enjoy reading your HN posts. But that doesn't prevent me from pointing out flaws in your logic. If my original reply sounded like an attack, then I guess I should be more careful in my wordings.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:00AM (#3028884)
You responded to someone attacking me for mentioning gold with "not only that, he..." EG: You agreed with him.

My original reply did account for the transaction fees in "pay no interest loans". I didn't use the same figure you did, but to pretend like I ignored it is wrong. If you had read my post, you would notice that I said that a "safe investment" like a CD would not give you a sufficient return at current CD rates, and so I talked about a hypothetical %6 CD.

Your original reply came as piling on, and since you didn't (and still haven't) recognized that I had addressed the issue you're bringing up, there's no way to distinguish you form the others who are jumping in and telling falsehoods about me based on their own financial ignorance.

I am quite dismayed that nobody has responded on the original point-- using arbitrage to finance your startup-- and instead people are trying to score points by attacking me as if this were reddit.

I'm already pretty hesitant to post to this site due to an expectation that I won't useful discussion in response. This is just convincing me more of it.... so, if you do enjoy reading my HN posts, know that I try my best when posting to avoid stepping on any of the land mines that will result in people attacking me, and I post as if I'm walking on eggshells. I thought that mentioning gold might be tolerated here, but I was wrong.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:42PM (#3026667)
Maybe I should have been more clear. What you're arbitraging is two rates of return-- the interest rate of the loan, and the return of the investment. In more conventional arbitrage, you're buying a commodity at one price in one market and selling it at another price in another market at exactly the same time. Here you're doing that, only the commodity is money. (Gold is money.) You could substitute a foreign currency, or foreign bonds for gold in my example, just as easily.

In that case, you'd be borrowing US dollars and buying, say, Greek Bonds. I picked that example because greek bonds have a high rate of return. They're also debt... you're getting debt in one market and selling it in another.

Greek Bonds obviously have risk. All arbitrage has risks, and those risks can be huge. That the risk is huge doesn't make it any less arbitrage.

FWIW, I don't think gold is at a particularly high price. I think the dollar and other currencies, which have been long over valued, are a little less overvalued than they were. I don't price gold in dollars, I price dollars in gold.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by derobert on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:11PM (#3027052)
You're missing the key point of arbitrage: its risk-free.

Say you borrow $100k at 0% for 1 year. You then buy (at $1734/oz) ~57oz of gold. Next year, you plan to sell it and pay off your $100k.

But you've taken a risk. If gold is only $1500/oz next year, you're going to lose ~$13k. Of course, if its $2000/oz, you're going to make a nice profit. You're speculating on the gold market. You could build a similar position with gold futures, for example.

Arbitrage would be if you could take that $100k, and immediate buy gold in USD, sell it in EUR, and then buy USD with those EUR and wind up with >$100k. Then you're not taking any risk, because you can set up all those transactions practically at the same time (and the markets are liquid enough you know the prices you'll be able to buy/sell at).

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by 2arrs2ells on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:32PM (#3027150)
While the academic definition of arbitrage requires it to be risk-free, in practice there is always risk of some form.

If you're buying gold in SF for $100 and selling it in NYC for $101, you carry the risk that the price will move while you're executing the trade.

If you're doing the yen carry trade (borrowing yen, and lending dollars), you carry the currency risk.

If you're taking 0% credit card loans and buying CDs, you carry the default risk on the CDs (mitigated, of course, by the FDIC).

That said, I agree with your general point - buying gold with a 0% loan carries so much risk that it's really just a leveraged investment, not an arb opp.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:13AM (#3028914)
You are assuming the person doing this has not also bought puts against the gold sufficient to cover the long position.

There is no such thing as "not taking any risk" or a "risk free" investment. The idea that arbitrage is without risk is, kinda amusing, if you think about it.

Even buying the put options I described to protect the position involves risk, though it does reduce the level of risk dramatically.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by feral on Thursday September 22, 2011 @09:41PM (#3028508)
I'm afraid you don't understand the point of arbitrage, at all.

As others have said, by definition, an arbitrage is risk free (or, in practice, nearly risk free).

Buying extremely risky Greek Bonds, with borrowed USD, is just making a leveraged investment.

Considering the transaction costs you'll pay, as a small time buyer, and the various worked in charges, you will certainly be losing out, when the risk etc is factored in.

Its a bad way to fund your startup; its up there with buying lottery tickets, or playing roulette to make more money: might work out ok, sometimes, or even all the times you try it - but its a negative expectation thing to do.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:04AM (#3028892)
The problem is you do not understand risk at all. You compare things with many orders of magnitude different risks as if they were equally risky. In fact, in my original post, I addressed the issue of risk, and mentioned hedging that risk using put options. Yet, you think that because you're not sophisticated enough, or didn't bother to actually read my post, you think you can spout off and accuse of saying things I did not say. In fact, you claim that I "don't understand the point of arbitrage, at all", on the basis that you are unable to price risk accurately, or do not understand the concept of hedging.

But hey, just keep on thinking that gold is very risky.... sucker.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by dasil003 on Friday September 23, 2011 @04:46AM (#3029306)
You're claiming gold is not risky? You're like the cheap little ads plastered all over the back of magazines trying to sell you gold. If gold is such a sure bet, why are so many people so desperate to sell it to you?
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:01PM (#3030450)
You put words in my mouth and then you characterize me. This makes you consistent with the rest of the commentators. This is why you can't have good discussion on HN.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by dasil003 on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:39PM (#3030599)
Maybe you're not as clear a communicator as you think.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by klochner on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:44PM (#3026678)
so by your definition, any leveraged investment is arbitrage.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by barrkel on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:58PM (#3026737)
I don't think so. It's about the price of money. If you can buy money for rate a, and sell that money elsewhere for rate b, where a < b, then it's arbitrage on the price of money.

(Where price of money is a synonym for interest rate.)

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Thursday September 22, 2011 @01:12PM (#3026792)
Exactly. I'm guessing people have trouble seeing money as a commodity that can be arbitraged.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by feral on Thursday September 22, 2011 @09:44PM (#3028517)
Gold is not the same as USD. It is a different asset to USD, and carries different risks.

The Greek Bonds you mention, you also consider 'money'. Well, not all 'money' is the same. That's why you get paid more if you buy Greek bonds than if you buy German Bonds, to the same Euro value: risk premium.

Its not arbitrage if you are just being paid for taking on risk, by definition.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:16AM (#3028920)
I wrote my post, presuming anyone who might follow such a strategy was sophisticated enough to understand what risk is. Risk can be hedged. Risk can also be calculated.

You're right that gold is not the same as USD. It is less risky.

You'd do well to not tell me what I believe about various asset classes, especially when it is clear you have not even read the original comment I made.

By definition, people engaging in arbitrage are being paid to take the risk that the arbitrage might fail. The idea that there is such a thing as a risk-free form of property is fallacious.

Thus your arbitrary demand that I be talking about something risk free is an impossible standard (and quite off the point... but then, maybe derailing the possibility of sophisticated financial discussion was your goal?)

I mentioned hedging risk, and everything else you've brought up in my original comment.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Thursday September 22, 2011 @12:58PM (#3026736)
I, in fact, did not say that, making this a non-sequitor.
Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by Retric on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:55PM (#3028146)
The problem is you assumed it even if you did not say it. The are basically two ways to do arbitrage one is to execute the trades fast enough that the prices are fixed. Or do a closed transaction where the underling commodity price is irrelevant and you make money even if the price spikes or drops. AKA buy a directive of a stock and short that same stock. You can still be bitten if one of the counter-party does not finish the transaction but at least on paper your safe.

PS: Get a loan at 0% interest, buy an option on gold at 1000$ and short gold at 1100$. Now most of the time things are priced in such a way that you will lose money on this trade however if people are selling the options to cheaply then you could execute this trade and be guaranteed to make money. Assuming the people that sell you the option don't default. Unfortunately, you can make money by selling options worth more than your capital so you come out ahead on average and if bad things happen you are ridiculously broke but effectively still at zero. Sort of like me making a billion dollar bet that the redskins don't go undefeated this year, it's easy for me to price those risks based on the idea I would only go broke in such a way it they seem really attractive even if they are next to worthless.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:50AM (#3028868)
No, in point of fact, I said the opposite. It is a shame that HN has become a place where people don't bother to understand the point someone is making, lie about them, and then the person gets down voted to negative territory when they try to defend themselves.

Not a single response to my comment has been on the actual topic of this submission. Most of them have been frankly, dishonest, and the only thing I'm concluding from this is that this site is inhabited by people who are such financial neophytes that they think there's such a thing as a "riskless transaction".

So, no, you don't get to assert that I assumed something and then call me a liar when I point out that I didn't say it, especially in the face of me pointing out the difference between leverage investments or margin investments and arbitrage in the original comment, which is proof positive that I didn't say they were the same.

Or, well, you can do that, but you force me to conclude that this is not a place where intelligent discussion can take place.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by Retric on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:07AM (#3029700)
"Dollars spent to pay off a loan are worth less than dollars you get at the beginning of the loan. This means, the asset you put your money into, needs to return not only enough to cover the interests & fees on the credit cards over the time period, but the monetary inflation rate over the time period."

Sorry, but on top of confusing leverage and arbitration (AKA arbitration works even if your not taking out a loan but you can use a loan's leverage to increase your return). Your also making the mistake that inflation is bad when you hold another asset. If you buy 1000$ worth of wood and you get significant inflation that wood is going to be worth more dollars not fewer dollars when you sell it. When you get a loan inflation is good and deflation is bad, when you give someone a loan inflation is bad and deflation is good.

PS: When you get a loan you are required to pay back X% more than than you borrowed but that percentage is normally independent of the inflation rate for some period of time. It's true that with CC they will adjust their rates based on inflation, but the only reason this could work is the rate is fixed for some period of time even if inflation changes.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by nirvana on Friday September 23, 2011 @11:59AM (#3030438)
You quote me saying the correct thing about inflation, then you provide an example that is consistent with what I said, and then you claim that I am ignorant.

All in a thread where I responded to someone who lied about what I said, and pointed out that I didn't say that at all, and in fact, I said the opposite.

But what I actually said does not matter to you, or others commenting here. You're dishonest, and a perfect example of why HN sucks for trying to have a worthwhile discussion.

Re:Don't try this at home. How credit card arbitrage funded ... by Retric on Friday September 23, 2011 @03:51PM (#3031335)
I don't think we are communicating vary well.

"Dollars spent to pay off a loan are worth less than dollars you get at the beginning of the loan." (This is Correct)

"This means, the asset you put your money into, needs to return not only enough to cover the interests & fees on the credit cards over the time period, but" (up to here everything is fine) "the monetary inflation rate over the time period." (This is literally true, but misses the point while inflation makes this easier not harder if inflation is meaningful your not doing arbitration.)

The point I am trying to make is if you have a 0 interest loan for 1 year and you buy a 1 year bond that pays 1% interest then great you have arbitrage. But, if you have that same loan buy a 2 year bond with a that pays 2% it's become speculation because the value of a 2 year bond in at 1 years is dependent on inflation and you either need to sell that bond at market rates or get a new loan. So, if inflation is important your not doing arbitration.