You're basically saying that the average state of the stock market and the economy is to be average and not non-average. Ok, that's true by definition. The point is that people who have even marginally better understandings of how it plays out in the tail events can make enormous amounts of money. Even those people would agree that the average case is for there not to be an issue.
Market's are efficient, thinking that that means they are always right is a drastic misunderstanding of what EMH says. Were markets right in mid 2008? Clearly not. And people were specifically calling for and profited off of what happened.
Take your example 2008, how would you use that information from the past to time the stock market today? Unless you have some information the rest of us don't have, you could be sitting on S&P Put options for the next 10 years.
The (few) people who profited in 2008 realized the subprime mortgages were rotten to the core before any media or masses knew what a subprime mortgage was.
This isn't comparable to the information we all have today that covid is here, interest is high, and russia is teeing up the border, which is already priced in.
>This isn't comparable to the information we all have
there's no set of information we all have. plenty of people don't believe covid is real, and that russia is run by reptilian aliens. Markets efficiently value their "knowledge" just as much as anyone else's.
This is the point though. Like what today?
If you have some theory why the Market is mispriced I'm all ears, but saying "plenty of people don't believe covid is real, and that russia is run by reptilian aliens" isn't really an argument.
You are the one making the case that everyone else is wrong, so the burden of proof lies with you.
credit bubbles often pop when some institution can't cover its obligations, but asset bubbles don't seem to need such a failure — and can deflate on their own.
Everybody can see danger if there's a red flashing "DANGER" sign blaring.
The point is to be ready before you see that flashing sign and not get caught up in a mad scramble.
We're seeing the danger signs: inflating currency and families paying far more for living expenses.
Heed the warnings or not, but they exist.
It’s a reflexive system.
Honestly- unless something has demonstrably “broken,” such as Lehman or AIG collapsing, then nothing systemically has actually changed.
There is so much nonsense and speculative Austrian economic discourse every time the market hits a speed bump that you can’t actually rely on anything anyone says.
Here is the real test for you: “have you seen any major institutions fail, implode or go under?”
If not, we aren’t in trouble yet. The stock market and economy have incredible ability to make adjustments, rebalance and repair themselves when provided information and time.
Yes the federal reserve will raise interest rates.
But that doesn’t mean the entire economy will implode. It might just mean that resources are allocated from some sectors to others.
This information is almost entirely priced in now. Unless more surprises occur (unexpected rate hikes or rate hikes happening too fast, or more rate hikes announced or institutions randomly imploding because debt burdens too high, or Russia invades Ukraine) we are probably ok.
And then again; the federal reserve is not a passive actor. They might announce a rate increase, watch what happens, then change their minds if things correct too far.
Suddenly your Peter Schiff scenario changes under your feet as the federal reserve unleashes the flood gates after allowing a calculated cooling off in speculation.
So that’s it: Has anything failed yet? Any imploding banks? Did Russia invade? If not, we aren’t in crisis mode yet so just chill out and watch.
If you are worried about a crisis; watch for institutional failure as your signal that real crisis has arrived. Everything else is just hot air.