What other things frustrate you about finding things to do in a foreign city?
Our solution is a bit different - namely avoiding curation by a few people. We're frustrated by how difficult it is to find things to do in a new city, and we want to get locals to help (after all, the best way to visit a city is to visit a friend who lives in that city). Think crowdsourced walking tours.
We can take this discussion off HN, too. My email is in my profile.
Travel guides are inherently for tourists looking to see these little kitschy places.
There a phonebox near my house that's pretty run down, cleaned once a year, smells of pee and often has those seedy cards in it. It's not well maintained.
But it's constantly being photographed by tourists. Every time I walk past it there's someone taking a picture.
Why? Because it's one of those classic red booths and you can spot it if you're visiting Nottingham Castle.
Tourists can love stuff that looks mundane to the locals.
The conversation then turned to strange things [Neil Gaiman] has witnessed while in the US: a large decommissioned nuclear submarine docked by a road in Portsmouth, NH that locals barely take notice of; cheese-wheel rolling festivals; and people parking their vehicles on frozen lakes in the American heartland. He noted that, “The UK is weird, but not as weird as here!”
http://www.comicbooked.com/neil-gaiman-american-gods-anniver...
In another comment of yours you mentioned appealing to the lowest common denominator... I see what you are saying but that also means "the average" person. You are less likely to be wrong suggesting the Cheers bar then a local favorite.
tl;dr: Gowalla wishes they got some of that Where money. I just searched for "marijuana" in Amsterdam and it returned two results. One was the Hemp Museum. You're better off asking a surly local or a fellow tourist.