Re:I would like a job writing Haskell
by Kototama on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @09:48AM
(#30259007)
I'm not that familiar with Rust at the moment, could you expand?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I would like a job writing Haskell
by ReleaseCandidat on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:18AM
(#30259360)
To use traits like you would type classes in Haskell, for example to define functors or monads in a general way, you need higher kinded types. Which can kind[oh, what a pun] of be implemented in Rust.
So yes! You can use higher kinded types in rust. Whether you should I will
leave up to you. But it certainly doesn't seem like a very attractive option
for most projects considering the syntactic noise of the implementation, a
typechecker that gets often confused and requires help, as well as error
messages that don't make much sense. Especially the last is a shame since
extremely helpful error messages is what rust is known for, and I
wholeheartedly agree (under normal circumstances).
https://hugopeters.me/posts/14/ Yes, But Why, Really?
Because sometimes one just gets homesick for Haskell and wants to implement
the Functor hierarchy. You'll find this in the higher-cat crate. It's not
really very suited for writing good Rust code, but it makes Haskell
programmers feel happy and it has a lot of funny words.
https://docs.rs/higher/latest/higher/A proposal for an addition to Rust, to get generic monads and (Haskell-like) do-notation for them:
https://varkor.github.io/blog/2019/03/28/idiomatic-monads-in...
Re:I would like a job writing Haskell
by benreesman on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:11AM
(#30259277)
GP is referring to a Rust language feature called “traits” that is a quirky subset of a Haskell language feature called “type classes”.
Type classes are based on firmer theoretical footing (I think the original paper is called “Making Ad-Hoc Polymorphism Less Ad-Hoc”) and therefore run into fewer weird corner cases.
That’s not to say that Rust traits are “bad”, they’re useful and arguably cleaner than the C++ version of the idea (“concepts”), but a Haskell hacker writing Rust is liable to grumble now and again at the weird edge cases.