News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla FSD beta crashes into object [video] by ajross on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:17PM (#30236560)
> I've yet to be convinced we are anywhere close to meeting the bar on that if.

What would convince you? Data from 60k cars isn't sufficient?

Re:Tesla FSD beta crashes into object [video] by Volundr on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:20PM (#30236585)
> What would convince you? Data from 60k cars isn't sufficient?

It would be if the data showed they were safer than human drivers, and was independently obtained. I have yet to see any data that suggests this or anything close to this.

Re:Tesla FSD beta crashes into object [video] by olliej on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:10PM (#30238909)
The Tesla data shows that they are less safe than regular drivers
Re:Tesla FSD beta crashes into object [video] by ajross on Monday February 07, 2022 @01:30PM (#30248963)
Uh... no? I suspect you're referring to the Goodall preprint that did the rounds a few days ago. What it purported[1] to show was not that AP was less safe than regular driver, but that it was less safe than Tesla claimed. It still showed that it was (moderately) safer than Teslas being driven without active safety measures, which are themselves about 3x safer than average vehicle.

You seem to have taken the opposite conclusion, which is exactly what the feeding frenzy over the paper wanted.

[1] The methodology is hugely suspect: you can't take an incomplete data set and then just "correct" it by inventing axes that you pull in from other incomplete data sets that weren't studied or measured in the original! That's rank P-Hacking. It seems reasonable, but I guarantee that a talented statistician can push any such data set 2x in either direction with that kind of trick.