Re:Ask HN: Is GitHub Copilot / IntelliCode Legal?
by anon2020dot00 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:16PM
(#30235887)
My impression is that this goes to show how poor GPL and other copy-left licenses are. Basically a person is never allowed to look at GPL code if that person will ever have a possibility of writing commercial software.
Github Co-Pilot will most likely not be used to directly compete with GPL-licensed software but the argument of the copy-left organization is that even using snippets of it is not allowed. So basically GPL is really a poor idea of open source, imo, since they make it open for people to view but you can't really use it.
If you even read a piece of GPL snippet, you have to erase it from your mind when you're working on a commercial software.
The Software Freedom Conservancy has skilled lawyers who think Copilot/etc. isn't legal: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2022/feb/03/github-copilot-co...
Until there are court cases that set precedent, nobody will know for sure.