News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by dannyw on Sunday February 06, 2022 @09:59AM (#30233063)
This is a warrant:

1. Issued in relation to attempted arson, which I think we all agree fits closer with "serious crime" than "civil disobedience"

2. The warrant is detailed and specifically identifies two specific subjects, identified through CCTV footage and described in the warrant.

3. Is approved by a magistrate in a federal court.

4. Is issued for a specific location and a specific timeframe (75 minutes).

5. Is for a specific record of movements during the location and time, without account details, before the FBI asks which account details they want to subpoena.

Let's look at the fourth amendment:

    The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized
Is there probable cause? Indisputably.

Was the application made under oath? Yes.

Is there a specific place? Yes, both in terms of space, and in terms of time.

Does it clearly describe what to be seized? Yes.

Has a warrant been issued by a Magistrate after review? Yes.

Sounds good to me. I oppose mass surveillance (fuck you, NSA), but this seems constitutional and reasonable to me.

[dead]
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by dannyw on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:24AM (#30233296)
> False, the warrant asked for data for all devices in a geographic location, they were then trying to use that data to find to individuals.

Page 17: Page 17: "(a) [...] Google will not, in this step, provide the Google account identifiers (e.g. [email protected]) associated with the devices" "(b) [..] The government may, at its discretion, identify a subset of the devices" "(c) [..] Google will then disclose to the government the Google account identifier associated with the devices identified by government"

The warrant specifically addresses Google.

> The courts rarely reject any warrant requests, this should give everyone pause for concern

This could also mean law enforcement generally only issues warrants when there is probable cause and legal basis to do so; such as in this case. This warrant being unsealed and public also means the public can review it.

I am absolutely concerned about the encroachment of civil liberties, constitutional rights, and privacy. This specific example is not a battle I would disagree on, or fight.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by crmd on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:25AM (#30233297)
What scares me about these scenarios is how it fabricates durable probable cause on the basis of being in the vicinity of the wrong place at the wrong time. Imagine becoming a felon because the police searched your phone and found a discussion between you and your friend about buying LSD, and discovering that the legal basis for that search was that your phone was in the vicinity of a crime scene a couple of years ago. This is bad news.
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by Fnoord on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:14AM (#30233834)
There's a simple way around that: any evidence found for crimes, can only be used to prosecute the original crime involving the law why the warrant was issued. Everyone else is offtopic, and therefore discarded. I know, there's parallel evidence, but the fact its possible doesn't mean such should be used.
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by krisoft on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:54AM (#30234259)
It becomes very hard to discuss these things when we are mixing up what we think the law should be with what the law is.

What you are saying is a reasonable proposal, but it is not how it works now. And it is very unlikely to change in the close future.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by Fnoord on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:31PM (#30234691)
I don't know how US law is, but in The Netherlands this would've been unlawful evidence [1].

[1] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onrechtmatig_verkregen_bewijs

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by vel0city on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:11PM (#30235169)
The US has a similar idea of illegally obtained evidence, its a very common concept. This is different from the above suggestion, which is essentially any unrelated evidence of crimes found while executing an unrelated search warrant is void. For example, a warrant is issued to find documents related to criminal fraud, while searching someone's office for materials related to the fraud they find a pile of illegal drugs. In the above suggestion, they wouldn't be able to prosecute drug violations as they discovered the drugs during an otherwise lawful search but its unrelated to the crime the warrant was issued for. The original search wasn't illegal, just that the second crime wasn't related to the issued warrant.
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by x86_64Ubuntu on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:10PM (#30236490)
"Vicinity of a crime" has already gotten people arrested. And of course, since in the US, the process IS the punishment, the guy lost everything.

https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/google-geofence-locatio...

Even fitness app data has been used to finger the wrong person.

https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/7/21169533/florida-google-ru...

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by isomel on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:14PM (#30234469)
> Imagine becoming a felon because the police searched your phone and found a discussion between you and your friend about buying LSD, and discovering that the legal basis for that search was that your phone was in the vicinity of a crime scene a couple of years ago.

I fail to understand what's wrong with that. If you did commit a felony, should you not be prosecuted for it regardless on how it came to light?

(Now there is the question whether buying LSD should really be a felony, but that's a different problem entirely)

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by syshum on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:27PM (#30237668)
No it is the same problem

Overcriminlization of society leads to people using this defense for more and more drag net style surveillance in order to "catch the criminals"

It has been studied and there is a good case to be made that the average person commits 3 felonies a day, there is no single person in the nation that know every single law, regulation, or ordinance one must follow, and some are written in such away criminal defense lawyers call them "catchall" felonies that are specifically designed for plea agreements, to get people to plead out to a "lesser" offense just so the felony would go away

Since the 90's we have expanded the number of "crimes" that classify as felony as well, when most people think about "felony" they think about violence, this is far from the case today when there are TONS and TONS of non-violence offenses that are classified as felonies.

Beyond drug laws, there are all manner of federal and state regulations that can be a felony

[dead]
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by rdtsc on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#30233818)
Fire can kill and seriously injure people. If this kind of weapon does not justify a warrant, what does?

I can see making a case that nothing justifies it, as a principle, but not sure I agree that Molotov cocktail is just a harmless toy idea.

> These are very marginal actors doing something that can't really cause large scale damage

Just curious how would we know that? It’s nice if it was true, of course, but is it?

[dead]
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by josephcsible on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:55AM (#30234263)
To be clear, are you saying that it's okay to set people on fire who you think are corrupt?
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by Ekaros on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:55AM (#30233633)
So you would be entirely okay with police not trying to use available information to find a person throwing molotov cocktail at your house or you?

After all they are marginal actors and single person or home isn't large scale damage?

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:15AM (#30233847)
I'm ok with throwing a molotov cocktail at corporate/police property as a response to police killing people and getting away with it.

There are few "reasonable" options for redress or protest when the system itself is guilty and successfully sweeping nonviolent protest under the rug.

Those who feel more instinctive revulsion to intentional property damage than to injustice against human lives are part of the problem and must change. Property is never more important than human life.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by throw_m239339 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:40PM (#30234812)
> I'm ok with throwing a molotov cocktail at corporate/police property as a response to police killing people and getting away with it.

You're OK with someone setting a precinct on fire at the risk of actually killing people inside or in the surroundings? People that might have had nothing to do with whatever crime the police got away with at first place?

You're not seeking justice, you're seeking vendetta, so why are you acting like justice has not been served at first place? You don't believe in Justice anyway.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:57PM (#30234991)
No, Im not okay with risking killing people. I was clear that i believe human life > property. Im ok with damaging empty police stations though.

>You're not seeking justice

You're placing a higher value on property than on human (black) life.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by throw_m239339 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:02PM (#30235743)
> No, Im not okay with risking killing people. I was clear that i believe human life > property. Im ok with damaging empty police stations though.

No you don't, you are okay with risking killing people. How did these protester know the police station was empty? They didn't. You condone violence.

> You're placing a higher value on property than on human (black) life.

Liar, these molotov cocktails were not thrown at buildings ,in a attempt at arson, for the sake of black people.

And don't make it about black people, like all that violence was for the sake of black people, it wasn't, it was for the sake of violent individuals who clearly didn't care about the consequences of their actions, actions you condone.

Don't use black people as a shield for your violent ideology.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:59PM (#30236945)
>No you don't, you are okay with risking killing people

This is literally and precisely what I am against.

>And don't make it about black people

It is about the correct response to people who get away with literal murder.

>like all that violence was for the sake of black people

Or for murdered people who did not receive justice.

>clearly didn't care about the consequences of their actions, actions you condone.

This is precisely the problem. What are the consequences if a cop murders someone and gets off?

If the state does not ensure consequences for the guilty then is the state not guilty?

And if the state is guilty, what should its punishment be?

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by CodeGlitch on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:24AM (#30233951)
I'm not. I don't want mob rule or anarchy. There are plenty of examples of people bringing about social changes through peaceful protests and other means.
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:31PM (#30234687)
If the police exist to steal your money, beat and kill you with impunity the mob rule is already here it just isnt evenly distributed. The molotov cocktails are a trailing indicator.

Violent protest paired with nonviolent (e.g. Malcolm X + MLK/ireland/india) has a better track record of success at bringing about change. The Iraq war protests serve as an example of the failure of nonviolent only (and those protests were huge).

For the white liberal living in safety you can condemn the burned out police station and dead body equally. That's definitely your prerogative.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pstuart on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:22PM (#30235309)
I stand in support of BLM, as in its core tenet, but I don't support that violence. In fact I think much of the violence associated with these protests are the work of agents provocateur working to delegitimize the movement. And it seems to be highly effective.

A sampling of such here: https://www.counterpunch.org/2020/10/08/protests-provocateur...

This isn't to say that some "real" protesters might not get caught up in the melee once it starts, but it's clear that outside agitators are actively working to destroy it.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:01PM (#30236967)
It's interesting the number of people who state that they generically "don't support violence" as if there were no meaningful distinction between violence against a person and violence against a window.

Is it that you see an attack on a person as equivalent to an attack on a window?

Or if not, why blur the distinction?

I think that the peaceful anti-Iraq war protests of 2002 serves as a poignant example of what happens when you have a large and entirely peaceful protest. No windows got smashed in London. Only in Baghdad.

I actually dont think I can think of a protest that was that large and failed so utterly in what it set out to do.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pstuart on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:47PM (#30237347)
I'm not blurring anything.

I'm stating that some of the violence associated with BLM is coming from people actively trying to discredit the movement. My gut tells me that it's a significant amount.

What I find more interesting is that people who make a point about the violence categorically seem to to ignore this aspect of the matter.

Are you willing to consider that this is happening, and if so, that perhaps that should bother you more?

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:23PM (#30237624)
No, I know some of it is police instigators but i dont think it's done to "discredit" the movement but to rile up and then entrap the peaceful protestors who can then be detained and prosecuted.

It bothers me but I consider it a separate issue.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pstuart on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:25PM (#30240413)
It's absolutely about discrediting it -- look at how effective it is, it worked on you. Your words indicate that as far as you're concerned, BLM == violence and destruction, period.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/not-accident-false-thug...

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pydry on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:31AM (#30241881)
>Your words indicate that as far as you're concerned, BLM == violence

It's pretty amazing that on this thread I have more people responding as if I said something completely divergent to what I said than responding to what I actually said.

It's a bit sad, kind of like being on cable news.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pstuart on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:59AM (#30269451)
Ah, went back to your parent comment and I apologize for my missing your original comment.

In my defense, my point still stands and it's a knee-jerk response to many here who equate BLM with violence, period. The detractors have done an excellent job in smearing the movement.

As to property damage, I recognize that there are understandable situations where that can occur but the real value is in the possibility of shit getting out of control vs mayhem on tap.

Public protest is an important civic action and those that work to undermine it should not be tolerated.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by pstuart on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @01:11AM (#30255423)
If I misread, I apologize and welcome correction. You misread me too, so it happens to all of us.

As far as the quoted text, perhaps I'm painting with a wide brush but I see a pattern here of framing BLM solely in terms of violence associated with it. Being that much of this is manufactured by interlopers I would hope that you would recognize how concerning that is.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by FredPret on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#30233351)
Are you listening to yourself?!

It’s only a little Molotov cocktail, no big deal, hope nobody dies in the ensuing fire that will by the way cause huge property damage.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by BuyMyBitcoins on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:02AM (#30233710)
“Fiery, but mostly peaceful”
Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by junon on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:00AM (#30233688)
> Throwing Molotov cocktails

> something that can't really cause large scale damage

What planet are you living on?

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by maxlybbert on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:14AM (#30233839)
> By your argument, you're okay with these sorts of requests for basically any crime. It seems to me that this kind of sweeping surveillance should only be used in extreme cases.

I’m not familiar with how police departments and prosecutors (or in this case, the FBI and the Justice Department) determine how much effort to put into solving any particular crime. I’m sure they wouldn’t put as much time into solving a misdemeanor as they would a felony, and that they would put even more time into a murder than a regular felony, but I doubt they would have very many rules about whether a specific type of warrant is reasonable for a specific type of crime.

I suspect that once federal investigators are involved, they probably take the position that it is an extreme case and any legal technique is justified.

Re:FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest at... by fortran77 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:33AM (#30233379)
Wow! I think you should reconsider your stand on throwing incendiary devices.