News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Expanded Child Tax Policy Slashed Child Poverty by colechristensen on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:57PM (#30229267)
Yes, if you draw a line in the sand as to what does and doesn't count as poverty and then give away a marginal sum of money, suddenly many people cross from nearby one side of that line to nearby the other.

Surely this makes a difference in the lives of these people but on large scales, how much of a difference have you actually made?

Effectively what you've erected is a subsidy for high rent and low wages which target the poor, there must be better solutions than solidifying the systematic problems which capture this segment of the population.

Re:Expanded Child Tax Policy Slashed Child Poverty by zozbot234 on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:21PM (#30229389)
> on large scales, how much of a difference have you actually made?

Giving cash to liquidity- and asset-constrained folks with high-value spending needs (like raising a kid) makes a huge difference if you can even roughly target the intervention to them. It's almost impossible to theoretically bound the benefit, it could be very large indeed. Even if some money were wasted on "bad" spending, and even though redistributing it is inherently costly, it's the kind of thing that's absolutely worth trying. It has all the well-known benefits of UBI, except on an even larger scale.

Re:Expanded Child Tax Policy Slashed Child Poverty by frgtpsswrdlame on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:16PM (#30229360)
>Surely this makes a difference in the lives of these people but on large scales, how much of a difference have you actually made?

Judging by the article, quite a large difference.

>there must be better solutions than solidifying the systematic problems which capture this segment of the population.

We're talking about poor children here. The systemic problem of this segment of the population is that they are poor. It's easy to talk about poor adults and prescribe behavioral adjustments, it's a way of assigning desert. It's much harder to talk about poor children because it's obvious that no child deserves to be poor.