News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by kingcharles on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:40PM (#30216533)
I just had my bank account terminated by Block (Square) because it was easier to boot their customer than deal with my support request which was outside of their pre-written script.

Their ToS of course allows them to terminate an account at any time for no reason. Their support staff keep saying that I violated the ToS, but they can't specify which one because of course they have no option in their system for someone who was terminated for NO violation of their ToS.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by tomschlick on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:16PM (#30216788)
I would say your next step is a complaint here: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/complaint/

Generally those get treated seriously by financial entities.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by imroot on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:32PM (#30217466)
I had 40K+ taken from me by US Bank after a payday in 2020. Writing the CFPB basically generated a response that "We're returning your money to the processors who send you money" from US Bank.

Guess who never reached out to me to ask why my bank was returning transactions? My employers.

When I called them to ask what had happened, their "Fraud Research & Gap Analysis" VP was shocked that this only caused a mild inconvenience to me (mainly because I split my payroll between a bank and a local credit union) and then pressed me to get the name of my credit union.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by aspenmayer on Saturday February 05, 2022 @02:49AM (#30218827)
> When I called them to ask what had happened

But what happened?? The suspense!

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by imroot on Saturday February 05, 2022 @05:22AM (#30219751)
Simple:

They closed my accounts, which, is something that they can do in the terms and conditions that you agree to when you sign up for an account. They did not disclose to me where the money in my checking account went to, because, according to them, they did not have to.

I realize that 40K isn't a lot to some folks on here, but, it was the money that I had set aside to go and do a fun project after COVID-19 had subsided (here we are, two years later): if the bank does something with your money that it doesn't have to a.) disclose what they did with it, and b.) be judge, jury, and executioner with it, I'm not sure a lot of folks would really appreciate that.

In the end, I was out 40K-ish, a few hours of my time, and a reply from the CFPB that didn't really solve my issue.

I can make more money.

I can't make more time.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by kingcharles on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:53AM (#30222989)
I did. I got a response very quickly. The response said absolutely nothing of value. It just said "We responded to your support request then terminated your account" but used 1000 words to say it.
Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by 0xy on Saturday February 05, 2022 @12:02AM (#30217704)
You hit a flag for suspicious behavior and they can't tell you exactly what was suspicious because this allows fraudsters and criminal networks to adjust their operations accordingly.

People don't just get terminated for no reason.

Either you were doing something sketchy or you were acting in a behavior that is similar to previous fraud/criminal behavior.

I'm a legitimate customer and my credit card has been flagged for fraud numerous times at large companies (Steam, PayPal, eBay etc). Often temporarily, however.

(source: have worked in various fraud/risk departments)

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by QuietCF on Saturday February 05, 2022 @03:25AM (#30219006)
Imagine if we were writing our laws like this, or court rulings would go like this.

“We can’t tell you what evidence we used to convict you because that would mean criminals can adjust their operations accordingly”

And then you hear someone say “people don’t get convicted for no reason”

I have no idea if the OP did or did not act fraudulently and I’m aware that we are talking about a private and not a government entity here.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by kingcharles on Saturday February 05, 2022 @12:02PM (#30223091)
I bought an item online. It was shipped, but never delivered to me and FedEx returned it to the merchant. The merchant does not reply to any communications. I had already asked Square for a refund before the package shipped (as it shipped 6 weeks late). It took Square three months to even respond to my chargeback request. They asked for copies of all communications and the shipping logs. I gave them everything. They said they could not do a chargeback since the package shows as "delivered" and their script does not allow them to deviate from this. We went back and forth because I thought they were confused about me receiving the package. They confirmed they were not confused and that they fully understood that the package had been delivered back to the merchant and was never delivered to me, but it was still technically "delivered" so it is not possible for them to do a chargeback.

After that all their support would tell me is that I need to call FedEx and trick them into changing the status on the package to "undelivered" and they would happily do a chargeback for me.

Once we had gone back and forth on this a few times they said they had decided it was better to just terminate my account.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by andreareina on Saturday February 05, 2022 @01:58AM (#30218544)
I hear this argument all the time. What I never hear is anything that actually helps to judge the trade-off. How often is a flag incorrect? How often is a legitimate user able to recover from the flag and how much effort does it take? I notice you say your flags have only been often temporary, i.e. sometimes permanent.

Are we really ok with throwing away due process because it might help the criminals? Sure nobody needs that game but access to money services is a bit different. And what you also never hear about is being refunded for all the content paid for in the blocked account.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by 0xy on Saturday February 05, 2022 @06:08AM (#30220021)
The justice system has thousands of false positives and throws innocent people in jail for decades sometimes. As a whole, society accepts some level of error margin in every facet of society.

After working in risk and fraud, I've seen some truly horrifying stuff. An elderly woman threatened physically if she didn't let the attacker drain her bank account. Huge scams for thousands of dollars. Organized crime rings fleecing millions of dollars. Identity theft. On and on.

I would wager that society would accept some level of errors in exchange for drastically reduced criminal activity that actually hurts people.

Legitimate people getting blocked inadvertently are rare, and often of the stories you hear on HN and Reddit and other places, a good portion of these "innocent victims" are actually doing sketchy stuff when you dig into it.

Justice isn't and cannot be an exact science. Society agrees and accepts the risk.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by andreareina on Saturday February 05, 2022 @06:16AM (#30220052)
I'm not asking for exact numbers. But let's have some numbers, because otherwise how can we agree to something when we don't know what we're agreeing to?
Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by 0xy on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:38PM (#30229485)
According to some studies, up to 1% of prisoners in the U.S. are innocent. That would mean 23,000 people wrongfully imprisoned.

In my experience, false positives in fraud and risk models are lower than 1%.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by mhitza on Saturday February 05, 2022 @02:15AM (#30218635)
They should at least tell you that a flag for fraudulent activity has been raised. At the same time I'd like for there to be some way to have an external auditor validate that it's not due to some bug or overzealous filter.

With GDPR such automated decision making can be stopped, and entities fined if not. Unless there's a big ol' exception for anything that falls under banking security & fraud.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by lmz on Saturday February 05, 2022 @03:06AM (#30218900)
Can't do that. "Tipping off" is a crime.
Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by devoutsalsa on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:46AM (#30222904)
When your account was terminated, what happened to your funds? Recovered? Lost?
Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by kingcharles on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:55AM (#30223005)
Eventually managed to exfiltrate it. I didn't have another bank account outside of Square, so I had to go and open one and was eventually able to get the money out.

Funny though - I tried to transfer the funds to my other Square account and it said "We cannot transfer funds to Square because of their excessive fees." WTF.

Re:Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content mode... by devoutsalsa on Saturday February 05, 2022 @12:16PM (#30223267)
Ugh. Glad you got your money out.