Re:Poll: Where do you live?
by onionisafruit on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:02PM
(#30214711)
As an American I do this because I always get the follow up question of where in the US. Itβs just more efficient this way.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If you asked someone where they're from, would you expect them to say, for example, Almaty instead of Kazakhstan?
Did you miss the part where OP said that most people expect them to specify which state they're from?
Whether you like it or not, it's usually insufficient for someone from the US to simply say that they're from the US. It's a big enough place with enough externally-visible cultural variation that people want to know.
Inside Argentina, if someone ask me where I'm from I', expected to specify the province where I'm from. (And in some cases, the part of the province, like "Santa Fe" and "Rosario".) My guess is that it happens in all countries. But if I talk with people that lives abroad, usually "Argentina" is enough. The US is not special in this.