News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:17PM (#30209620)
> "some folks just haven't noticed themselves"

Some folks don't enjoy tying themselves in knots. You are absolutely welcome to spend your precious seconds of limited life on it, but it doesn't make you superior, however much you would like to think it does. It's just a choice, like between working and playing.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by psyc on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:17PM (#30210726)
This is such a non-sequitur. I can't tell if you're referring to people choosing not to be conscious (I doubt that's possible) or choosing not to ponder on it (I don't think that's relevant). If people don't want to think about it, that's easily avoided. What we're talking about is people expending serious thought, "tying themselves in knots" as you say, to write essays and sometimes tomes dissuading others from pondering it either because "there's no hard problem" or "it's not productive."
Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:52PM (#30211227)
I am talking about choosing to tie yourself in knots and thereby preventing any further progress toward understanding what you are talking about.

You could also choose not to tie yourself in knots, and then you would not be blocked, and could begin to make sense.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by psyc on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:02PM (#30211355)
That makes more sense, thanks. But philosophers of mind, neuroscientists, cognitive scientists, and all could just as well pursue other lines of inquiry without protesting too much that there's no hard problem.
Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:52PM (#30212057)
If you think there is a hard problem, it is on you to articulate one. Thus far I have not encountered one that does not depend on undefined words or circular arguments, i.e. knots.
Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by rytill on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:32PM (#30212674)
Do you think there is such a thing as objective morality? Not just human ethics, or social norms or whatever, but that some things that occur are "better" than other things in some important sense. Or maybe, that certain actions are "good" and others are "bad"?

Like for instance, the experience a human would have when relaxing in a hot tub with their friends, is "better" in some important, real sense compared to the experience of dying in a trench in WWI?

If not, I probably can't convince you that there is a hard problem having to do with consciousness where we'd benefit from knowing all the answers. But if so, I could give it a try.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Saturday February 05, 2022 @06:23AM (#30220081)
There are certainly things I like better than other things. There is probably a fair bit of overlap with what you like, but also certain to be differences. Where they differ, am I right, or you? If one of us is not wrong, then one is not objectively better.

A system for understanding consciousness that depends on objective merit will face very stiff competition from those that don't.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by rytill on Saturday February 05, 2022 @07:17AM (#30220324)
Wouldn’t you say the experience of “being you” or “being me” would be part of the system of how consciousness works? And therefore, whether you like something or I like something, it’s part of the happening of consciousness.

Maybe “you like the experience of drinking tea” is a totally compatible statement with “I don’t like the experience of drinking tea” in an objective sense.

I would say it’s not that consciousness depends on objective merit, but that it could be the other way around.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by carapace on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:03PM (#30210297)
I didn't say anything about "superior".

Is being a "P-Zombie" inferior to being self-aware? By what metric could such a comparison be made? Is the water inferior to the wave?

Also, "tying themselves in knots" != "noticed themselves", if anything it's the opposite: all knots untie.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:59PM (#30211315)
All knots can be untied, if that is what you choose to do. But not everybody chooses that. Thus far you have not chosen that.

"Noticing yourself" is something literally everyone does. Not everyone ties themselves in knots. The alternative to tying yourself in knots is to think clearly without inventing falsehoods.

"P-zombies" is just another word for solipsism. The moment somebody proposes either, you know there will be no more clear thought.

Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by hiacynt on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:25PM (#30212577)
P-zombies and solipsism are two totally different things.
Re:What’s so hard about understanding consciousness? by ncmncm on Saturday February 05, 2022 @07:35PM (#30227979)
Yet, curiously similar.