People have not been getting money offline really since the Department of Justice handed out initial indictments in April.
The messed up thing about this is they had a sustainable money-printing-machine that only became an unsustainable ponzi scheme due to the greed and corruption of the owners.
Affiliates and paying affiliates had nothing to do with their downfall. Affiliates are a standard throughout the online gaming industry.
Affiliates being a standard or not has nothing to do with it, anyhody that takes money out of the deposits will accellerate the process, and affiliates took a substantial portion.
Typically if you deposit $100 a large fraction of that is immediately paid out to the affiliate. You then enter the game and if the total rake on your account ends up being smaller than what is left in your account after the affiliate has been paid then you were a net loss to the company.
Without an affiliate that would be much harder to achieve.
That said, I believe that the players are stupid enough to play until they are bust so that's mostly theoretical, so I agree that they were quite possibly sustainable but it would need some inside figures to be sure.
Affiliates do not automatically get a chunk of deposits. Usually there are two options. They get paid a small lump sum for each new player, say $25-50. Or they get paid a % of the monthly generated rake (MGR) minus fees racked up by players.
I've survived for several years based on other players' willingness to play until they bust. But you can look at Las Vegas, Atlantic City, etc. for evidence of the sustainability of gaming.
Edit due to not being able to reply: The rake sucks a lot for everyone. It turns small winners into small losers, or keeps consistent winners from being huge winners. It makes it so everyone gets less play for their dollar.
I know Pokertableratings has done some [very incomplete] tracking on player losses, but they don't have a record of every hand played.
That's a small lump sum, but with a $100 initial deposit that's 25% to 50%. If that were the only deposit ever made and everybody asked for their money back after folding their first hand they'd be bankrupt immediately.
So the cumulative rake must be pretty high for that to work, unless the stickyness is huge and most people do multiple deposits.
Do you have any figures with respect to total rake vs payout over a sizable sample of deposits? That would be interesting.
They'll basically need to generate the $25-50 in rake before the affiliate can get the bonus.
See http://www.pokeraffiliatesolutions.com/full-tilt-affiliate-p... for more
If what Felix wrote about FTP was accurate, FTP considered money from customers as assets, not liabilities, so that they could be disbursed to investors. It's a fundamental category error in accounting, and pretty clearly fraudulent, if it's as plain as that.
FTP was always going to fall apart, the government investigation into UIEGA violations triggered it sooner. It may have otherwise become a billion-dollar ponzi
I lost money in FTP and was a regular player (I noticed the dodgy merchant names on credit card bills years ago and knew what was up but kept playing)
Rake adds up quickly. If poker sites only carried enough money to cover player balances, they wouldn't suffer.
Pokerstars is an example of a poker site that successfully paid out to players.
113. Beginning in or around August 2010, Full Tilt Poker was often unable to find payment processors to withdraw funds from the bank accounts of its United States players. Instead of disclosing this fact, Full Tilt Poker secretly began to credit funds to players’ online gambling accounts that Full Tilt Poker had never actually collected from players’ bank accounts. As players gambled, and lost, these phantom funds, Full Tilt Poker developed an undisclosed shortfall of approximately $130 million owed to players that Full Tilt Poker had never collected because, in reality, these funds were never withdrawn from players’ bank accounts. The management of Full Tilt Poker, including the FTP Insider Defendants, operated Full Tilt Poker with the hope that only a small number of players would try to withdraw funds at any one time, and that Full Tilt Poker would regularly receive additional deposits in amounts greater than any withdrawal requests.
I'm glad I only ever played for matchsticks.
But atop the other allegations, and depending on the magnitude, it seems fishy... like a desperate move to give the insiders a bit more time to withdraw remaining funds or 'gamble for resurrection'.
Though I can't be sure, I'd assume that banks might hold a little bit higher percentage than what Full Tilt was holding.
From the full tilt poker homepage:
"System Update
We apologise but the system is currently down. Please check back later. Please direct all enquiries to [email protected]."
wsj article:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405311190410670457658...
Layman explanation: Full Tilt Poker runs a wallet system, the sum all the users money is smaller than what they have in their bank accounts.
The 'Ponzi' element comes from their ability to attract new players at such a high rate that they can pay the withdrawals.
What makes it doubtful that this really is a Ponzi scheme is that - a bank run excepted - they probably would end up not paying out a very large percentage of the money they owed if operations continue, simply because most of the those playing online poker get fleeced incrementally, every dollar placed as a bet has a rake associated with it and that rake could cumulatively be a large percentage of the total money deposited. I don't run an online casino so I have no clue how often a given deposited dollar passes the tables before being withdrawn.
If there was one part here that is sloppy/criminal then that should be that they overpaid their affiliates.
A typical Ponzi scheme does not have affiliates taking a bunch of money of the table.