News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:04PM (#30195064)
You proved my point! The data shows that between renewables, storage, transmission, heat pumps, and electrifying mobility, climate change can be solved. There is thread after thread after thread chock full of citations on this matter. And yet you say, without the slightest hint of proof, that’s it’s a belief versus data.

It’s astounding really, and these data points have helped me recalibrate my expectations of fellow humans, as well as my empathy for them.

Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by CrazyStat on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:19PM (#30195327)
>The data shows that between renewables, storage, transmission, heat pumps, and electrifying mobility, climate change can be solved.

Gonna need a link to one of those threads full of citations on this claim, because this is not at all my understanding. Even if we had a magic wand that would reduce anthropogenic CO2 (and other greenhouse gas) emissions to zero overnight, we're already far above historic atmospheric CO2 concentrations and will be paying the price.

Edit: since I'm asking for citations, here's mine[1] showing that according to climate models zero CO2 emissions from 2020 onward would have little effect on the global mean temperature through 2100.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-17001-1/figures/2

Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by burkaman on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:08PM (#30197140)
It just depends on your definition of "solved". If solved means "all consequences of anthropogenic climate change avoided" then it's obviously too late, there's no solution other than time travel. If solved means "humanity survives as a species" then we're in pretty good shape no matter what we do. For most people I think solved means "we avoid the worst effects", which of course leads to another question about definitions.

Many people look at the graph in your citation and see it as a picture of success, because the baseline in their mind is RCP8.5. Note that the graph makes a comparison to RCP2.6, which is not a "do nothing" scenario, it's a pretty optimistic and aspirational future.

Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by KittenInABox on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:52PM (#30195905)
My understanding is that all that technology can slow the influence of the existing damage of climate change, not solve it. This is partially because climate change is an ongoing phemomenon that 1) has already happened; 2) is currently happening; 3) will continue to happen. In order to "solve" climate change one would have to go back in time.
Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by soco on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:17PM (#30195295)
There's a big difference between "technology can save the world" and "technology saves the world". Right now we see a lot of talk and very little action so indeed, I wouldn't rely as of yet on technology either.
Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by pessimizer on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:48PM (#30195844)
I'm normally simpatico with you, but I need you to help me find the data that says that this will work without cutting energy consumption in rich countries, and do that without creating a permanent underclass of poor countries forcibly held to a lower consumption rate than than those rich countries.

I have yet to see a scientific case for luxury communism where every Indian peasant gets their own suburban yard.

edit: and I do see a lot of people saying that technology right around the corner will just solve the problem without anyone having to change their lifestyle in the slightest.

Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:08PM (#30196165)
The alternative is billions dead and cultural extinction - at best.

"I didn't want to cut down on drinking/CO2/media pollution/etc so I killed myself instead" - which of these is a winning move?

Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by CrazyStat on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:24PM (#30196420)
The problem, of course, is that the people who would need to cut down the most are also the people least likely to die.
Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by gus_massa on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:55PM (#30198689)
Not everyone is so lucky to just cut media pollution. Imagine a subsistence farmer that wants a tractor so the children don't need to help in the field and can go to school. That would increase the carbon footprint of the family.
Re:Ask HN: General Mood of the Community by cableshaft on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:11PM (#30196212)
Didn't realize I was going to have a defend a PHD dissertation with my comment, especially since I don't claim to be an expert on climate change or anything, this is mainly what I've gathered from a few books and many articles and news stories I've read.

The biggest problem I see with 'technology will solve everything' beliefs (evidence-based beliefs are still beliefs) is that these solutions are almost always in a people and political vacuum. They assume that there will be nothing stopping or slowing it down or even reversing it from happening, from people not wanting wind farms in their back yard[1], to human nature prioritizing short-term issues over long-term threats[2][3] and voting accordingly[4], the inability for a people to enforce change on a global level (even if the US behaves perfectly, how are they going to get China[5] or India[6] to go to zero emissions without going to war with them...we saw this exact problem play out with the Covid pandemic, although the US was one of those bad actors). And politicians themselves have little-to-no incentives to stop climate change[7].

You even got people like Biden, who says "climate change is the number one issue facing humanity"[8], and yet he's caught falling asleep at the COP26 climate summit[9] (which does not help the image of how seriously the US is treating climate change) as well as approving new drilling permits for oil and gas extraction, at a faster rate than even Trump[10]. And lobbyists are able to kill climate change legislation just by putting some cash in the right politician's hands (Manchin in this case)[11].

There's other issues with the actual feasibility of the technology as well, such as we might not have enough materials for all the solar panels and wind turbine we'll need to build[12] (and the actual study they cite here[13]). But that's really a whole separate thing I don't have time to hunt down the articles for right now.

We wouldn't be in this mess in the first place if it weren't for people's actions, and now fans of the technology think everyone is going to magically do a full 180 on their behavior and fall in line for something they can't even see beyond some wildfires and stronger hurricanes, which they dismiss as freak events just as easily and keep their heads in the sand.

If anything it appears to me that we're going to wrong direction as far as the human and political element is concerned. Yes, some things are getting better, but we need massive global systemic change decades ago and that's clearly still not happening today, despite great progress on Solar and Wind affordability and EV cars (as well as other initiatives).

I'm not saying we shouldn't pursue these technological solutions as much as we can, far from it. I just think because of various reasons it's not going to get us to where we need to be, and more work needs to be done on trying to rewrite the brains and incentive-structures of people and politicians or we're almost certainly not going to meet those goals, and that's being glossed over in favor of saying "well, technically it can still be done!"

[1]: https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/2021-4-fall/feature/nimby-...

[2]: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=553048...

[3]: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190109-the-perils-of-sh...

[4]: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/13/the-no-1-esg-issue-for-ameri...

[5]: https://e360.yale.edu/features/despite-pledges-to-cut-emissi...

[6]: https://www.reuters.com/world/india/exclusive-india-may-buil...

[7]: https://theconversation.com/cop26-why-politicians-have-littl...

[8]: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/24/joe-biden-climate-change-is-...

[9]: https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2021/11/02/joe-biden-doz...

[10]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/01/2...

[11]: https://www.npr.org/2021/12/20/1065695953/build-back-better-...

[12]: https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a25576543/re...

[13]: https://www.metabolic.nl/publication/metal-demand-for-renewa...