It's a US legal system thing. I don't know the law by name, but a contractor can only be kept on for a period of 6 months to a year. After that, they must be made full-time or removed. After a cool-down period, they can be rehired.
Some companies are getting around this legally but hiring companies to outsource, and yet embed, contractors into the client's office under a managed service agreement.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permatemp#Vizcaino_v._Microsoft
That means as a contractor you can't be forced to come into the office at 9:00 AM to work till 5:00 PM, if you are not allowed to set your own work schedule you are not considered a contractor and the company should be paying your taxes and you should be getting a W2 instead of a 1099.
They were fairly strict in that regard as well, my boss was paying me as a 1099 and I wasn't aware of this, and the business got audited by the IRS and he had to retroactively pay taxes and they talked to me and I had to redo my taxes for the two years I worked there. Was a nightmare.
More details at: http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=99921,00.h...
Thanks, Microsoft permatemps. Litigious bastards.
So when contractors aren't an option management switches gears and says "We're providing all these benefits and growth potential. Hire the best people you can get in this salary range." And what you get, instead of superstars, is plodders.
Basically, a contractor (by the nature of its name) is supposed to be hired for a fixed-length period of time. I would guess that's what the tax laws are trying to enforce.
(Where I work, all contractors come in through third-party companies that pay the employees as W2s. They limit being a contractor to 18 months because then people can start suing to get benefits, like an invite to the Christmas party and healthcare. Or so I've been told.)
Is that true? I know of contractors from other countries who have worked in the U.S. for the same company for more than five years. And these companies are Fortune 500 so I assume they have a pretty rigid legal team.
An independent contractor can only work 6 to 12 months before being let go? Absolutely true. I saw it with my own eyes. An independent contractor returning after a few months of break? Absolutely true. I also saw this.
But a US law? You're right, it may not be a real law. However, when the legal department comes down and says that contractors cannot stay longer than X months because of a previous lawsuit at a company, I'm going to rightly assume that they don't want to break a law. And the way you said "if you are a business walking up to the line of the law", I'd guess that you agree that there is some sort of law that may be broken if companies aren't careful.
I was merely pointing out the real problems that companies face by employing contractors, instead of giving a blanket "Untruth!" statement.
And if only comprehending the full breadth of that experience is as simple as hunkering down and reading it all!
I had the privilege there of working with some insanely dedicated people, smart, hard-working, and good, who were kept on near-permanent contractor status, and then unceremoniously dumped when the legal limits for contract lengths came up.
And these weren't warehouse workers, these were HR folks, recruiters, technicians, and the such - people in positions that are neither seasonal nor temporary.
Beyond the moral/compassion concerns of this, it wreaked havoc with the team to have a good hire on board for most of a year, and suddenly have him/her replaced with someone unknown who needed even more retraining. It also placed a constant load on the people involved, since you're essentially always re-hiring the same position, over and over, with the requisite interviews and costs. Suffice to say it caused a lot of disruption with the team, and I have to question the wisdom of dragging down the productivity of a dozen people to save money on one.
I can't say I know the official (or unofficial) reasoning for this, though of course the usual suspects of paying out benefits comes to mind. Also, certain headcount metrics may exclude contractors, which might be a way for management to look like they're keeping headcount down while still getting the hands they actually need. Either way, it soured my faith in the company some, and with a bunch of other factors led me to depart from the company.